In the last 20 years, interest in dissociation in psychotherapy has grown , a period during which the psychotraumatological perspective has also increasingly established itself, with the extension and increase in complexity of the concept of trauma .
The origin of psychological and emotional malaise has in fact increasingly shifted towards the identification of events with traumatic impact and the plurality of manifestations of traumatic symptoms and their frequent correlation with dissociation has been highlighted (in DSM 5 dissociative disorders are reported in the vicinity of disorders related to trauma or intense stress).
The indisputable empirical picture is that the traumatized person frequently presents a complex symptomatological picture that goes beyond the diagnosis of post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and in both simple and complex post traumatic pictures dissociation is a recurring and distinctive element.
Many scholars in fact converge in indicating dissociation (together with emotional dysregulation and somatization ) as an indicator of the chronic post-traumatic condition, recovering what Janet and Freud had already expressed since the end of the 19th century, identifying dissociation as the underlying mechanism of hysterical pathology of traumatic origin.
What is dissociation?
To understand dissociation it is useful first to understand its opposite, namely integration. Each of us was born with a natural tendency to integrate personal experiences into a coherent and unitary life story, with a stable sense of “who is”. Our ability to integrate helps us to distinguish the past from the present and to maintain the sense of being in the present even when we remember the past or think about the future. Each of us develops typical and relatively stable ways of thinking, feeling and acting and we refer to this as a whole by the term “personality”. And we maintain the perception of who we are also by fluidly changing thoughts, emotions and choices of actions.
Understanding dissociation begins with realizing that human persons (whether dissociative or non-dissociative) are universally made up of parts. We all have parts (separate states of mind) in our personalities capable of engaging in tasks of daily life by coexisting, integrating and alternating and of which we are aware.
The dissociation is a serious difficulty in the integration of these parts, which interferes with the sense of self of the person and the personality, changing it. In dissociation, one part of the person possesses the experience while another part does not; people who suffer from dissociative disorders do not feel integrated, but fragmented, since they have memories, thoughts, emotions, behaviors that they experience as strange and not their own, as if they do not belong to them. They do not experience a single sense of self and they do not experience themselves as belonging to a single person.
These divided senses of self and ways of responding are called “dissociative parts of the personality”. It is as if there are not enough links or mental connections between one sense of self and the other. For example, a person with a dissociative disorder may have the experience that some painful childhood memories are not his (“I’m not that child”). This lack of awareness and realization, this “not me” experience is the essence of dissociation . It can take place in stages and take many forms. There may be a complete lack of mutual awareness between parts of the personality or one part may be partially aware of another part.
Typically there are two types of parts: one part has the function of managing daily life and to do this it is focused on avoiding traumatic memories; other parts (one or more than one) are instead blocked in the traumatic experiences and continue to live in the past tense as if it were the present and think, act and perceive as if the trauma was still ongoing or about to happen again.
It is therefore mainly emotional parts, with limited ability to think, which feel overwhelmed and often remain stuck in repetitive behaviors aimed at protecting themselves from trauma, but not adaptive with respect to the real present moment.
The dissociative parts can have different degrees of awareness of each other, but even when the parties are aware of their mutual existence may disagree on important issues for the person, depending on what are their meanings and their functions within the person himself.
Some are young parts, children, who often express a need for security, consolation, closeness; other parties may experience these needs as excessive or dangerous (given past experiences); then there may be parties fighting the threat; parts that are ashamed; parts full of anger and rage that mimic the behavior of the attacker; parties that try to kindly help the other parties.
What are the symptoms of dissociation?
Most people with a dissociative disorder do not come to therapy recognizing and complaining about a difficulty with their sense of self. They usually seek help for other problems such as depression , anxiety , sleep disturbances or relationship difficulties. They often describe symptoms that they perceive as strange, frightening, and that make them feel “crazy”.
One of the main symptoms of dissociation is the sense of involuntary: when a person is aware of emotions, memories, thoughts, behaviors but experiences them as if they do not belong to him. There may be the feeling of having different “voices” or identities that can also be perceived as very different from each other by age and with different degrees of functionality and complexity.
Some dissociative symptoms concern “experiencing too little”: there may be amnesia, that is, lack of memory and loss of some memories, which goes beyond normal forgetfulness, the gravity of which runs along a continuum.
People with dissociation may remember some aspects of an event, but not other essential aspects of the same situation. In other cases the entire memory of certain events is inaccessible. Sometimes people “suspect” that something has happened to them, but they have no recollection of it and can feel fear just thinking about it.
Amnesia can therefore concern the past but also the present: when you find yourself in a place without knowing how you got there or you discover that you have done something but without remembering that you have done it. These symptoms, when they are not part of a “normal” inattention, are linked to the fact that every part of the person is engaged in a behavior and other parts are unaware of it.
Other symptoms are depersonalization and derealization . The first is the sensation of feeling alien to oneself, of looking at oneself from the outside, as if one were looking at another person. In some cases the perception of certain emotions or parts of the body may be missing; people can remember what happened in a given situation, but as if it didn’t happen to them. This way is functional to keep the distance between oneself and terrifying or unbearably painful experiences.
Derealization is instead the experience of feeling unreal what surrounds us, things and people. Everyday environments may appear unfamiliar, a person who knows himself well may appear stranger; the surrounding world may appear as if immersed in fog and distant voices.
Other symptoms of dissociation concern “experiencing too much”. These are intrusions, when a dissociative party invades the experience of another through flashbacks of past traumatic events, memories, feelings, impulses or behaviors that emerge unexpectedly and suddenly; unexplained pains or other sensations that have no medical cause; internal voices or experiences that the person does not experience as their own. This occurs when a dissociative part of the person enters his waking awareness, and at that moment the person finds himself being “informed” of some aspects of what that part is experiencing.
How does dissociation originate?
Dissociation usually arises when an experience is so threatening or overwhelming that it cannot be fully integrated, particularly if adequate emotional support from other people is lacking. The chronic dissociation can then become a strategy of “survival” for people who have dealt with early childhood trauma.
The dissociation provides the person, at least to a certain extent, the ability to move forward in their daily lives and avoid coming into contact with the experiences of the past and present extremely stressful. However it also leaves one or more parts of the personality stuck in unresolved experiences, in the experience of trauma, while another part of the personality goes on in daily life constantly trying to avoid these painful and unintegrated experiences.
There are biological, social and environmental factors that make people more vulnerable to dissociation . In particular, young children are less able to integrate traumatic experiences than adults due to the fact that their brains are still immature; their personality and sense of self are still not solid and cohesive enough and in the face of such experiences they can lead to their disintegration and fragmentation.
There is general consensus that major complex dissociative disorders typically develop in childhood, especially for children experiencing severe neglect and abuse, and its effects persist into adulthood.
The knowledge on the functioning of the nervous system helps the understanding of dissociative processes by describing, from a physiological point of view, the stress and defense mechanisms. Our body is continuously engaged in assessing the danger and our possibilities of managing environmental demands. In case of danger we have the possibility to implement 3 possible responses: attack-escape; freezing (freezing) and faint (fainting / detachment).
The fight-flight response is an activation hyper-reaction mediated by the sympathetic part of the autonomic nervous system; if this strategy is not considered practicable, freezing allows the organism to immobilize itself (so as not to be seen by the predator); but when none of these strategies seem possible, the extreme answer we have is faint, that is the abrupt and extreme reduction of muscle tone accompanied by a disconnection of the higher centers from the lower ones.
This means that with the persistence of extreme stress states the autonomic nervous system can switch from hyperactivation to underactivation. The dorsovagal part of the autonomic nervous system is thus activated, responsible for bringing the organism into a condition of disengagement, passivity, submission, flattening of affects and energy, which allows a reduction in metabolism and an extreme attempt at defense: state of fake death, typical of animals when they are in extreme danger. In this situation there is detachment from experience and an insensitivity that is at the origin of the possible dissociative drift.
Current conceptualizations therefore clarify how dissociative disorders “make sense” in the context of a difficult life story. In therapy this type of conceptual understanding is often a crucial tool for helping patients suffering from dissociation to understand their own “normality”. Many people who were previously considered “untreatable” or “unable” to change can now be helped with targeted therapeutic treatments.
Attention to the cognitive and emotional aspects of trauma is certainly important, but clinical evidence and research in psychotraumatology highlight the need to deal more directly with the body, where the memories of the earliest experiences, even normally inaccessible, remain written. to explicit memory.
Pat Odgen’s sensorimotor therapy looks in this direction , just as Porges’ polyvagal theory describes how neurovegetative dysregulation is a consequence of the chronic activation of the person’s defense systems in the face of severe and continuous traumatization.
The multi-year work of clinicians such as Jim Knipe and Dolores Mosquera has led to necessary and fundamental adaptations for the use of EMDR therapyin complex traumatization. In these cases, the standard protocols leave room for a long and essential work of stabilization and strengthening of the patient’s emotional regulation skills, who must first of all be able to feel safe; awareness and dialogue with and between the parties; of seeking a collaboration between the parties in the internal system of the person, continually reorienting oneself in the space and time present, where it is possible to experience safety and remain within the emotional window of tolerance, only within which it is possible to elaborate unresolved traumatic memories directly.
We can only underline how important it is to have knowledge of dissociative processes and symptoms, so that their eventual presence can be grasped and understood even when underlying other problems brought directly to the attention of the therapist. This is both to make the treatment truly effective and to orient the therapeutic intervention in a dimension of optimal safety for the person who carries within him important traumatic experiences in relation to the world, to others and to himself.




