Coping

Coping This concept has been important in the field of psychology for more than 40 years. During the 1940s and 1950s, it represented an organizational concept in clinical description and evaluation and, today, it constitutes the center of a whole series of psychotherapies and educational programs that aim to develop adaptive resources. The subject of coping has also received a lot of attention in the mass media, as can be seen by flipping through the index of any magazine, the book sales lists or the programming guides. Actually, the word coping is both a colloquial and a scientific term. Despite its prolific history and current popularity, there is still a lack of coherence in terms of theories, research and understanding of the subject.

Summary

[ hide ]

  • 1 Traditional approaches
  • 2 Coping Traits and Styles
  • 3 Pattern A as a coping style
  • 4 Cognitive styles
  • 5 Field dependence and independence.
  • 6 Limitations and shortcomings of traditional approaches
  • 7 Coping as a trait or style
  • 8 Coping versus automatic adaptive behavior
  • 9 The confusion between coping and results
  • 10 The identification of coping with the domain of the environment
  • 11 See also
  • 12 Source

Traditional approaches

We find the concept of coping in two very different kinds of theoretical / empirical literature: one is derived from traditional animal experimentation, the other from psychoanalytic ego theory. We have already commented something about the research based on the animal model of stress and control. This approach is strongly influenced by Darwin’s theories according to which the survival of the animal depends on its ability to discover what is predictable and controllable in the environment and thus be able to avoid, escape or defeat harmful agents. The animal depends on its nervous system to carry out the opportune discrimination for its survival.

In the animal model, coping is frequently defined as those acts that control the aversive conditions of the environment, thus reducing the degree of psychophysiological disturbance produced by them. For example, NE Miller ( 1980 ) says that coping consists of the set of learned behavioral responses that are effective in reducing the degree of anxiety by neutralizing a dangerous or harmful situation. Similarly, Ursin ( 1980 ) states that “the achievement of a gradual decrease in response in both animal and human experiments is what we call coping. The animal is learning to face the situation by reducing the tension it causes through positive reinforcement »

Some of the most interesting research carried out on the psychophysiology of coping and the cardiovascular response has been carried out by Obrist et al. ( 1981 ), in particular in their work on the concept of active coping, in contrast to that of passive coping. This author strongly suggests that active coping is an important mediator in the cardiovascular changes regulated by the sympathetic nervous system.

It is not surprising that, in general, we consider the animal model of coping as simplistic and poor in content and cognitive-emotional complexity. For example, the central theme of the animal model is the one-dimensional concept of drive or arousal, and all experimentation focuses primarily on flight and avoidance behavior. With this orientation there is little that can be learned about strategies, which, on the other hand, are of the utmost importance in human issues such as cognitive coping and defense.

In the psychoanalytic model of ego psychology, coping is defined as the set of realistic and flexible thoughts and actions that solve problems and, therefore, reduce stress. The main difference between the way of treating coping in this model and in the animal model lies in the way of perceiving and considering the relationship between the individual and the environment. Although behavior is not entirely ignored, it is considered less important than the cognition factor.

Another difference between the two models is that psychoanalytic ego psychology differentiates between various processes used by the individual to manipulate the individual-environment relationship. For example, Menninger ( 1963 ), Haan ( 1969 , 1977 ) and Vaillant ( 1977 ) offer a hierarchy in which coping refers to the more organized or mature processes of the ego; This is followed by defenses, which refer to neurotic forms of adaptation, also hierarchically distributed, and lastly, there would be the processes that Haan calls fragmentation or ego failure, which Menninger homologates to regressive or psychotic levels of behavior.

In one of his early formulations, Menninger identifies five regulatory orders or resources, ranked according to the level of internal disorganization they indicate. At the highest point in this hierarchy are the strategies necessary to reduce the tensions caused by stressful situations that occur in the course of daily life. These strategies are called coping resources and they include self-control, humor, crying, cursing, lamenting, bragging, arguing, thinking, and releasing energy in one form or another. They are considered normal or, at the very least, idiosyncratic characteristics. However, if such strategies are used inappropriately or in an extreme way, such as when a person talks too much, laughs too easily, He loses his temper very often or seems wandering and aimless, then they lose their status as coping resources and become symptoms that indicate a certain degree of lack of control and imbalance. The greater the internal disorganization, the more primitive the regulatory resources become. For example, second-order resources include dissociation abandonment (narcolepsy, amnesia, depersonalization), abandonment to frankly more hostile impulses (eg, compulsions, rituals), and substitution of the self or part of the self as an object of aggression displaced (self-imposed restraint and humiliation, self-poisoning or drug abuse). Third-order resources are represented by episodic explosive behaviors, or aggressive energy, more or less disorganized, These include violent assaults, seizures, and panic attacks. The fourth order represents an increase in disorganization and the fifth is the total disintegration of the ego. In this system, the coping resources are those that indicate disorganization and minimal disruption. Any sign that indicates lack of control or imbalance, by definition, is not a coping resource.

Vaillant’s ( 1977 ) defenses are organized into four levels that progressively range from psychotic mechanisms (eg, denial of external reality, distortion and illusory projection) through immaturity mechanisms (eg, fantasy, projection, hypochondriasis, behavior aggressive passive), neurotic mechanisms (eg, intellectualization, repression, reactive training), up to the highest level, that of mature mechanisms (eg, sublimation, altruism, suppression, anticipation and good humor).

Same as Menninger ( 1963 ) and Vaillant ( 1977 ), Haan ( 1969 , 1977) also uses a hierarchical system to classify ego processes. This author proposes a tripartite hierarchical organization: coping, defense and fragmentation and identifies each level by the way in which an underlying generic ego process is expressed. For example, the generic process of symbolizing meaning is expressed as a logical analysis at the level of coping, a rationalization at the level of defense, and a conspiracy at the level of fragmentation. Sensitivity is expressed as empathy at the level of coping, projection at the level of defense, and delirium at the level of fragmentation. The main criterion that Haan uses to define the processes in the coping method is that of adherence to reality; if a person distorts “within-subject” reality, that person is not coping ….1977 ,. The underlying assumption is that:

“… it is better to know exactly the intra-subject and intersubject situations and act in accordance, than to distort or deny one’s own evaluations and actions. The value then lies in the accuracy in … interpersonal exchanges and to know what serves to verify reality social and personal as defined by common agreements about the nature of our mutual experiences. ”

Coping traits and styles

The psychoanalytic models of ego psychology that have dominated coping theory have also dominated its measurement. However, the measurement objectives to which these models have been applied have generally been limited to classifying individuals in order to predict how they would cope with some or all of the stressful events they may encounter. This application of the psychoanalytic model of the self results in considering coping structurally, as a style or trait rather than as a dynamic process of the self. For example, a person can be classified as conformist or pampered, obsessive-compulsive or as suppressive, repressive or sublimating (cf Loevinger, 1976 ; Shapiro, 1965 ; Vaillant, 1977).

A coping style differs from a trait, primarily in degree, and generally represents broad, generalized and encompassing ways of referring to particular types of individual such as the powerful or powerless, the friendly or hostile, the controlling or permissive, or to particular types of situations such as ambiguous or clear, imninent or remote, temporary or chronic, evaluative or non-evaluative. Traits, which refer to the properties available to the individual to apply in certain kinds of situations, generally have a less broad spectrum. Examples of traits that have been identified with coping include repression-sensitization (eg, Krohne and Rogner, 1982 ; Shipley et al., 1978, 1979 ), “bad mood” and “good mood” (eg, Funkenstein, King and Drolette, 1957 ; Harburg, Blakelock and Roeper, 1979 ), coping-avoidance (eg, Goldstein, 1959 , 1973 ) or control-brusqueness ( eg S. Miller, 1980 ). (For a more comprehensive review of trait measurements, see Moos, 1974. )

Some of the richest descriptions of coping styles based on the model of ego psychology are those that can be found in clinical case reports, an example of which is the work of Vaillant ( 1977). This author examined data collected over 30 years for male college graduates and then questioned each of them. His impressions coincided with those of the researchers who had preceded him and from them he extracted a detailed description of each subject. Furthermore, the behaviors presented in moments of crisis and conflict were interpreted by the experimenters as the defense mechanisms they suggested. Approximately half of the subjects presented by Vaillant in his cases are demonstrative of their particular styles of establishing relationships with others, of facing problems, and of pursuing commitments and given goals. He also deduced from these analyzes,

Unfortunately, descriptions of coping styles that are based on case analysis tend to be idiographic portraits rather than examples of common coping styles. As such portraits, their usefulness is limited and therefore they do not facilitate interpersonal style comparison or group analysis. In addition, case studies used in research have the practical drawback of requiring large amounts of time and money to collect and analyze data.

Pattern A as a coping style

The conceptualizations of the style of coping that we have described previously appeared from the psychology of the ego; the concept of pattern A has more to do with behavior than ego processes and has a completely different air.

We have already mentioned the phenomenon of pattern A in Chapter 1 in a quote from Mr. William Osler, which shows that the assumption that certain types of life increase the risk of cardiovascular disease has a long tradition in the history of medicine. This assumption was supported empirically by the research of Friedman and Roseman ( 1974 ), who defined pattern A as a “chronic and incessant effort to improve more and more in less time and, if necessary, against the opposition of things or people” . We will not consider the enormous literature that exists on the subject. Given the interest in the relationship between pattern A and maintenance of health, we will at least briefly consider whether this phenomenon is related to some coping style.

Pattern A is a constellation of three concepts among themselves a set of beliefs about oneself and about the world; a set of convergent values ​​in a model of motivation or commitment (eg, commitment to work); and a behavioral lifestyle (eg, impatient and competitive) – operating in a wide variety of social contexts. Although authors and researchers have insisted on one or the other of these concepts, they should be considered as interdependent psychological aspects of the same phenomenon. The psychometric aspects are also of interest to researchers on the subject. It is not clear whether pattern A is better defined by referring to it as a typology or as a dimension between the extreme pattern A and the extreme pattern B.1982 ], which defends them). Other psychometric aspects are those that refer to the best way to measure the pattern. In an extensive review of the subject, Matthews ( 1982) identifies three types of measurement: the Jenkins Activity Inventory, the Framinghan Scale, and the structured interview. The first two are questionnaires filled out by the subject himself and the third, a procedure used by Friedman et al. That includes the evaluation of language and social behaviors, as well as the expressive aspects with which the individual responds to the questions. Matthew notes that the three measurement procedures turn out to have “only a slight margin of agreement.” The desire to understand the psychological characteristics of the behaviors typical of pattern A has led researchers to study the reactions of subjects A and B to various stressful tasks and situations (Diamond, 1982 ; Lovallo and Pishkin, 1980; Pittner and Houston 1980 ; Yamold and Grimm, 1982 ). Some researchers, such as Vickers, Hervig, Rahe, and Rosenman ( 1981), have searched for a link between pattern A and self-advocacy activity. These researchers found that the structured interview measurements were not related to the defense factor, whereas with the questionnaires “work involvement” correlated with high scores in coping and low in defense. This led them to formulate the interesting hypothesis that the increased risk of cardiovascular disease only appears when pattern A is combined with poor coping resources. Can pattern A be considered as a coping style that includes several interdependent behavioral, cognitive-affective and motivational aspects? Without a doubt, the behaviors displayed by pattern A include what we call coping; for example, redoubled efforts to achieve greater control of the situation and strategies that allow accepting the lack of such control without causing any disturbance. However, with the exception of Vickers and colleagues (1981), researchers have generally not attempted to explicitly measure coping thoughts and behaviors as their focus has been on job performance. Therefore, to speak of Pattern A as a coping style is to make an interpretation, our interpretation to be exact, but it is also something that can be demonstrated. Speaking more broadly, coping styles generally have great theoretical potential. A taxonomy of coping styles that brings together the richness and complexity of all adaptive processes can help in the systematization of research on the relationship between coping and adaptive outcomes, not only in the context of health and disease, but also within the context of family and work. The careful development of such a taxonomy could be an important contribution in the study of thestress .

Cognitive styles

The psychological model of the self also gave rise to a whole structure of theory and research on cognitive styles. These styles refer to automatic responses rather than to those that obey an effort and, therefore, we do not consider them coping styles. (We will discuss the question of automatic versus coping responses later, which involve effort.) Thus, cognitive styles serve as control mechanisms and their effects bear some resemblance to what we sometimes mean by coping style.

Cognitive controls. Gardner, Holzman, Klein, Linton, and Spence ( 1959 ) developed the concept of cognitive controls to describe the attributes of perceptual and memory apparatuses that function outside of ego conflicts. Cognitive controls are styles accepted as important mediating variables in maintaining the stability of the individual’s attitudes and orientations. They are considered operations of structures of the ego that act to provide an adaptive balance between the internal efforts and the demands of reality.

A cognitive control would be that of leveling-sharpening, which would be related to the balance between new stimuli and memories of previous experiences. Leveling expresses the tendency to see things in terms of similarities or similarities. The exacerbation, on the other hand, is a way of seeing things based on the differences they present. Other cognitive controls are focalization or scanning, important to determine the spontaneous attention given to different situations, the equivalence range, important to establish judgments about similarities and differences, flexible and narrow control, which decides the response to the perception of incongruous situations and the tolerance to unreal experiences,1959 ).

Field dependence and independence.

The global analytic dimension developed by Witkin and his colleagues is a good example of another cognitive style with roots in perception and ego psychology (for a more extensive review, see Witkin, Goodenough, and Oltam, 1979 ). His work began with an analysis of the trends of dependence and field independence (cf. Witkin, Dyk, Faterson, Goodenough and Karp, 1962). These two styles are evaluated through tests based on the way in which each subject configures their spatial perception. In these tests, the subject sits in a darkened room in front of a device with a luminous moving spot. The device is tilted by the experimenter and the subject is asked to place a line perpendicular to the device. A large inclination of the line indicates obedience to light signals, while a line in a vertical position indicates independence of the visual field and confidence in the position of the body. The purpose of this test is to analyze the extent to which subjects use external signals from the visual field or the body itself as a point of reference to position the perpendicular direction.

Limitations and shortcomings of traditional approaches

A number of problems limit the usefulness of traditional approaches to coping and the dimensions of trait and style. Some of these problems are not necessarily a consequence of existing theories, but appear as a result of the way these theories have been expressed regarding measures of coping. One could speak of four main aspects: the judgment of coping as a structural trait or style; the lack of differentiation between coping and automatic adaptive behavior; the confusion between coping and consequence and the equating of coping and mastery.

Coping as a trait or style

Traditional coping models tend to insist on traits or styles; that is to say, in structures of the self developed by the subject himself that, once created, presumably act as stable predispositions to face in one way or another the events of life. Although such a static and structural perspective is not formulated theoretically, structural concepts such as feature-style occupy a central place in practice and research. We end up talking about repressed or vigilant individuals, field dependents or independent, deniers, and so on.

If the determination of the coping traits allowed to predict what the individual will actually do to face certain stressful situations, the investigation would be something simple since all the intents and purposes of an individual would be determined by their traits. If a person faces the threat through avoidance, whenever he feels threatened, resort to such a strategy could be expected. However, the determination of the coping traits has had a very modest value in predicting the real coping processes The problems that appear when using the traits as predictors are well evident in the research on coping with the threat of surgical intervention, carried out by Cohen and Lazarus (1973). Surgical patients were interviewed in the hospital the afternoon before their intervention and the information each had about their disease and treatment was noted, as well as their interest in knowing more about both aspects. This procedure would allow knowing what the individual was thinking and doing in a given situation at the time the threat appeared, something that cannot be done by simply measuring traits. The patients ranged from avoidance, characterized by poor knowledge and the desire not to increase it, to vigilant coping, in which the subject already had a lot of information and welcomed any data that could increase it. Along with this direct assessment of coping, A classical measurement of traits was also performed using the Byme (1 964) repression-sensitization scale. No correlations were found between direct trait measurement and process measurement. This, by itself, prejoined the speed and the ease of recovery of the operation: the avoiders performed in this sense better than the vigilantes. Even more important for the question at hand is the fact that direct measurement of the trait did not predict how the individual would actually cope with the threat at the time of its appearance.

Coping versus automatic adaptive behavior

There is an important difference between automatic behaviors and exertional behaviors that is not evident in any of the traditional approaches to coping. The resources that human beings need to survive can be learned through experience. A useful observation about human adaptation is that the faster the individual can apply these resources automatically, the more effectively he can manage his relationships with the environment. We see an important difference between the early stages of resource acquisition, which require enormous effort and concentration, and the later stages, in which such resources have already become automatic.

For example, experienced drivers are generally unaware of when to use the clutch or brake, and they do not put forth much effort to carry out these operations. We do these things so automatically that, for example, we can go thinking about a work problem while we carry out these complex maneuvers to get to it. These acts are adaptive but cannot be called coping; If they were, then we could call almost everything we do coping. However, when something happens that is out of the routine, for example, a road closed for works, which forces a decision to be made such as going another route or a puncture that forces to change one wheel for another, then an effort is required . In all these examples,

The confusion between coping and results

In both animal models and psychoanalytic ego psychology, coping is equated with adaptive success, which also occurs in colloquial language. In the original sense of the word, saying that a person faces the demands of a certain situation suggests that such demands will be overcome successfully, and saying that a person will not be able to cope suggests ineffectiveness or insufficiency.

In the three psychoanalytic models of the self that we have described above, there is a hierarchy of coping and defense according to which some processes are automatically considered superior to others. For Menninger, the hierarchy represents the degree of disorganization or primitivization which, in turn, informs us of the intensity of stress. This is a completely circular analysis. For Haan, coping reflects a strong and well-functioning self, defense is neurotic behavior, and self failure represents the most disorganized degree of functioning.

When effectiveness necessarily implies coping and ineffectiveness defense, there is the inevitable confusion between the coping process and the result of such process. These conceptual systems are not appropriate for investigating the relationship between coping and outcome, so we must abandon the hierarchical approach and learn to study both aspects independently. To determine the effectiveness of the coping and defense processes, one must have an open mind to the possibility that both can work well or badly in certain people, contexts or occasions.

The identification of coping with the domain of the environment

There is an implicit corollary in the definitions of coping that consider certain strategies essentially better or more useful than others; that is, the best coping is the one that modifies the individual-environment relationship in the sense of improving it. Because they are so deeply steeped in Western values ​​that refer to individualism and dominance and also due to the impact of Darwin’s theories on psychological thinking, these definitions tend to confuse dominance of the environment as the ideal type of coping. Coping is considered the equivalent of effective action to solve problems.

The point is not that problem solving is not something desirable, but that in life, not all sources of stress are capable of being mastered or of being fitted into a plausible model. Examples of this are found in natural disasters, in inevitable losses, in old age, illness and the many human conflicts that psychology and psychiatry have been dealing with since ancient times. Insisting on solving the problem and mastering the situation detracts from other coping functions related to mastering emotions and maintaining self-esteem and a positive image, especially in irremediable situations. The coping processes that are used to endure such difficulties, or to minimize, accept or ignore them,

Once the traditional approaches to coping have been reviewed and their limitations and defects considered, we are now in a position to present our own definition and conceptualization of the process, in order to avoid past mistakes.

 

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top