Utopian Socialism: Meaning, Differences with Scientific Socialism and the Political Thought of Owen, Saint-Simon, Proudhon and Fourier.
Utopian socialism refers to the set of all the first formulations of socialist thought. This was established in France and England in the first half of the 19th century. Utopian socialism is different from scientific socialism : scientific socialism was born later and constitutes the most mature phase of socialist economics. Marx gave rise to these two terms: according to Marx himself , scientific socialism fled from reality without analyzing it.
Marx with his form of socialism, the scientific one, dealt with the study of society and its evolution. The most important exponents of utopian socialism instead are Henri de Saint-Simon , Charles Fourier, Robert Owen and Pierre Joseph Proudhon . These were called “utopians” because they intended to overcome the capitalist system and create a new type of society based on cooperation. They proposed a reform that concerned the matters that the state had to deal with: the state also had to worry about the redistribution of economic resources, private property was abolished even if little importance was given to the proletariat.
This social class is the one that in exchange for its labor force receives a salary. The socialists criticized some elements of the capitalist system such as income inequality, individualism and private property and claimed that the working class could also live better in the future like other social classes. Utopian socialism then proposed the transformation of the economy through various reforms and these had to concern the abolition of private property, the collectivization of the means of production, and the equality of all social classes. The utopian socialists proposed the creation of production and consumption communities called “Fourier” or phalansteries and factories that were protected by the state and managed by the workers (atèliers sociaux).
ROBERT OWEN
Robert Owen, an English entrepreneur and exponent of utopian socialism criticized capitalism and the way in which the proletariat was exploited and considered capitalism an immoral society. Owen’s aim was a society that had to be based on cooperation. Owen experimented with a new industrial model in his cotton mill where he granted decent wages, eliminated child labor and proposed better working hours. This was called “village cooperation” (Villages Cooperations) that redistributed wealth, he also proposed to the English Parliament to eliminate child exploitation but this proposal was blocked.
SAINT SIMON
According to Henri de Saint-Simon it was very important to increase national wealth with more work and more education. Furthermore, according to de Saint-Simon, society was divided into two parts: the first was composed of people who produce while the second is dedicated to idleness. He believes that the collapse of a state like France would occur by removing the elements of the first social class and even if some members of the second were removed nothing would happen.
Also important for Saint-Simon is technology, which inevitably increases production.
PIERRE-JOSEPH PROUDHON
Another important utopian socialist was Pierre Joseph Proudhon who proposed a society based on “positive anarchy” that is, on the self-management of workers . Furthermore, Proudhon argued that property was theft: the means of production and the house in which a person lives must remain with that person as long as he uses them. He distinguishes possession from property: property is an illegitimate good because it creates profit and generates instability while according to him possession is a legitimate good. He himself states that property is the suicide of society.
CHARLES FOURIER
According to Charles Fourier, the rigid division of labor imposed by capitalism mortifies the personality of the worker. Thus, Fourier designs “phalansteries” which are production units that also serve as residences for workers. In Fourier’s phalansteries, homes are hotels and everyone can produce what they like to produce and no one will be tied to a single job. Furthermore, according to Fourier, the capitalist society of that time failed because it did not bring the well-being it had promised.




