Plato’s Protagoras: explanation and commentary of the dialogue in which Plato questions Protagoras’ ideas on knowledge and truth.
The Protagoras is a dialogue by Plato featuring the sophist philosopher Protagoras. In the dialogue, Plato challenges Protagoras’ ideas about knowledge and truth, arguing that truth is objective and independent of individual perception. The Protagoras is considered one of Plato’s most important dialogues, as it addresses some of the fundamental questions of philosophy, such as the meaning of truth and how humans can know things.
SUMMARY
The dialogue opens with Hippocrates waking Socrates in the middle of the night to tell him that the famous sophist Protagoras is in town and that Hippocrates would like to become his disciple. Socrates tries to test Hippocrates’s determination and invites him to wait with him until daybreak. Meanwhile, he asks Hippocrates if he really knows who Protagoras is and what he thinks he can learn from this master, but Hippocrates realizes that he has no answers to these questions. During the dialogue, other characters also take part, such as Prodicus of Ceos, Callias, Alcibiades and Protagoras himself. Protagoras begins the discussion by stating that sophistry is the basis of human progress and the only science capable of teaching political virtue (the art of living in society), but Socrates disagrees.
To prove his point, Protagoras introduces a myth: Jupiter gave men justice and modesty, which are the foundations of political virtue. According to Protagoras, this is an innate virtue that must be harmonized with virtue in the general sense. Socrates asks whether the individual virtues are part of virtue in general or whether each of them is independent, and Protagoras argues for the independence of the various virtues. Socrates questions this statement, trying to refute it in two ways: first, he shows the connection between justice and sanctity, concluding that both have rectitude as their goal and are therefore equivalent.
Furthermore, he examines the relationship between wisdom and rectitude, stating that since both are contrary to foolishness, and Protagoras himself had previously stated that a concept admits only one opposite, these two virtues are also equivalent and can be traced back to virtue in general. During the discussion, there is a brief interlude caused by Socrates’ refusal to accept Protagoras’ magniloquence, which seems to hide the numerous contradictions he falls into behind rivers of words. Finally, Protagoras reluctantly agrees to continue the disquisition according to the conditions imposed by Socrates. The others present, Callias and Alcibiades, side with Protagoras and Socrates respectively . Subsequently, Protagoras begins a long excursus on the difference between the “difficulty of becoming good” and the “difficulty of being good”, based on the analysis of a poem by Simonides.
Socrates , using the same arts as Protagoras , ironically imitating his style, turns the speech on him and shows him that “no one does evil voluntarily”; then he resumes his questions and asks Protagoras if he remains of the same opinion as before.
Protagoras admits that the various virtues are similar to each other, but that courage is different from them. Socrates insists by observing that even courage, if it is not foolish temerity, can be traced back to the wisdom with which the courageous man disciplines his forces.
Therefore virtue is one and as such it must and can be taught.
In the dialogue there is a detailed description, and in some cases even a strong irony, of the sophists. Despite this, Socrates considers the interlocutor a person entirely worthy of respect and admires his erudition; equally Protagoras considers Socrates “worthy of excelling among his peers”. It is interesting how it falls to Socrates to demonstrate Protagoras
‘ initial thesis , which the sophist, who changed his opinion several times during the debate, had not been able to support, and therefore appears inferior to Socrates also in terms of argumentative astuteness. Moreover, only dialectics can support the sophist’s thesis, even though it had revealed its weak points.
COMMENT
Socrates never presents himself as an antagonist, but as a promoter of research that distinguishes good from evil, true from false, and is always ready to question himself and modify his thesis if he is convinced that it is not valid.




