Irish Question: Summary

Irish Question: A History Summary. From the Origins of the Clashes to the Last Years of the Twentieth Century.

The Irish Question

Between 600 and 500 BC Ireland was invaded by the Celts, who left decisive imprints on the culture of the island. Never subjected to Roman rule, Ireland was Christianized in 432 by Saint Patrick; the Irish ecclesiastical organization had a prevalent monastic character. Ireland was invaded by Nordic peoples.  The subsequent period was marked by internal struggles between the Celtic kings, and it was one of these, Dermot MacMurrough, who urged English intervention in the island, swearing allegiance to the English king Henry II .

Thus began a rapid and extensive conquest of Ireland by the Anglo-Normans, which culminated in 1171, when Henry himself settled in Dublin and from there began the introduction of the feudal system in Ireland. The essential factor of political stabilization was then the Church, which supported the conquest of the island. The integration of the two cultures was very problematic , due to the enormous political, cultural and institutional differences between the English and the Irish. While the most powerful English houses continued the work of colonizing Ireland, the country reacted with open rebellion (attempts in 1258, 1263 and the most significant in 1315-18, which however failed).

 From 1300 to 1600

The situation worsened in 1486, when Gerald Fitzgerald , Earl of Kildare, organized a further revolt; Henry VII responded by imposing, in 1494, the Poynings’ Act , which established that laws passed by the Irish Parliament had no value without the approval of the English king, while laws enacted in England must also be observed in Ireland. The complete subjugation of the island was accomplished in 1541 under Henry VIII .

 From 1600 to 1800

A treaty was concluded which granted the Irish the free exercise of Catholicism, but anti-Catholic laws were strengthened. This contributed to digging an unbridgeable gulf between England and Ireland; the Protestant aristocracy, the great majority of which were English, ended up with all the lands in their hands and living like an army encamped in the midst of a conquered people. Thus arose what was called the Irish question .

The British government, to avert the French danger, brought about the union of the two parliaments (abolishing the one in Dublin) in 1800, with the Act of Union : Ireland sent a representation of 100 deputies to the Commons and 28 peers to the Lords, while swearing loyalty to the English crown. But the most important problem remained the condition of the peasant class, oppressed by the obligations of the ” tithe “, that is, the tax destined for the Anglican Church .

 Revolutionary Action and Secret Societies

In 1842 the political movement of Young Ireland took on the plane of direct, revolutionary action. Around 1870 agitation resumed through the Irish deputies in the English parliament (called Irish nationalists ), led by Charles Stewart Parnell, who asked for Home rule , a law that provided for the establishment of a parliament in Dublin.

The usual hostile measures of the British government resulted in the revival of secret societies , which perpetrated a series of boycotts in the Irish tradition of protest. To obtain peace the government passed an Act in 1881 to relieve the conditions of the Irish rural tenants (who in the meantime had organised an agrarian league to claim their rights), but in vain. The resistance of Ireland did not cease.

 The Twentieth Century

In 1905 Sinn Féin formed an organised party. Following the 1910 elections, Home Rule was granted to the island , against which the Protestants of Ulster rose up, in order not to be subjected to the Catholic majority of the new parliament. In 1916, led by P. Pearse, the Irish Volunteers , Catholic military formations, rose up in Dublin (Easter Rising, in which Michael Collins and Eamon De Valera took part): the revolt was bloodily suppressed by English troops who, after bombing the city, executed the alleged leaders of the insurrection.

In the 1918 elections, Sinn Féin won a resounding victory, and in January 1919 a constituent assembly of Sinn Féin deputies (the Dail Eireann = Assembly of Ireland ), convened in Dublin, proclaimed the independence of Ireland and elected Eamon De Valera, then detained in English prisons, as president, while the immediately formed bodies of the Irish Republican Army (IRA) conducted a grueling guerrilla war against the English government soldiers.

 LIRA

The treaty establishing the “Irish Free State” , which granted Ireland dominion status within the Commonwealth with the obligation to swear allegiance to the King of England, and from which, by will of the Protestant majority, 6 of the 8 counties of Ulster remained excluded, which had already been recognised (1920) with a limited autonomy, was signed on 6 December 1921 in Westminster.

Shortly after the elections, the civil war began , due to an extremist, during which one of the major moderate leaders, Collins, was assassinated. In 1925, the Dublin government had to abandon the hope of a rapid reunification of the 6 Northern counties, counting on the fact that the two counties with a Catholic majority would choose to join the Free State, making the separate survival of the remaining 4 counties precarious. But this did not happen and an international commission sanctioned, in 1925, the separation. 1927 marked the return to politics of De Valera, who founded the Fianna Fail party (Party of Destiny).

The 1932 elections resulted in a victory for Fianna Fail , and De Valera became prime minister. In 1937 a new constitution unilaterally abrogated the 1921 treaty with Britain, ending the Dominion without London reacting.

Fianna Fail was defeated in the 1948 elections, and left the political direction to a coalition ministry headed by JA Costello, who was responsible for proclaiming the Republic of Ireland (17 April 1949). Returned to power again in 1951, De Valera was defeated by Costello in 1954, only to return to power in 1957 for 2 years. In 1957 he was elected President of the Republic, and was confirmed in 1966.

The early 1970s saw the country hit by the difficulties of a serious economic crisis accompanied by the consequences of the outbreak of the Northern Ireland crisis.

The History of Northern Ireland

The separation of 6 of the 9 counties of Ulster (Antrim, Armagh, Down, Fermanagh, Londonderry and Tyrone) from the rest of Ireland was the culmination of a centuries-old process of settlement by British Protestant settlers. The Catholic minority suffered discriminatory conditions from a political, economic and social point of view; this determined a state of tension between the two religious communities. The situation became particularly acute after 1960, when the serious economic crisis that was developing in England began to be felt heavily in the poorest regions of the kingdom, such as Scotland and Northern Ireland . In the latter, the first to be hit by the recession were, as often happens in these cases, the poorest sections of the population, that is, the Catholics: the drastic reduction in jobs caused their protest to explode in 1968, while the discontent of the Protestants – skilfully exploited by far-right groups led by the Reverend Ian Pasley – was channelled into positions of corporate defence of their privileges.

 The first accidents

The first major incidents occurred in Londonderry on 5 October, when a march organised by the Civil Rights Movement was brutally dispersed by the police. As the crisis progressed, the governing Unionist Party found itself torn between the moderate stance of Prime Minister O’Neill and the “hard line” of Minister Craig, so much so that it was unable to prevent the escalation of disorder and violence, which led to the direct intervention of the British Army in 1969. Throughout 1970 and 1971 the situation did not improve, until the Special Powers Act was passed on 9 July 1971 , which allowed the internment without trial of anyone deemed suspicious.

 Bloody Sunday

The protests culminated on 30 January 1972 with the Londonderry massacre, known as Bloody Sunday , when British troops opened fire on a peaceful Catholic protest march, causing 13 deaths. In response to the massacre, the IRA intensified its activity . The progressive deterioration of the situation led to the temporary revocation of Northern Ireland’s autonomy on 24/03/1972. However, hostilities did not cease. The IRA was opposed by “loyalist” paramilitary groups that unleashed attacks and killings of Catholic citizens. Between 1969 and 1985, 2,461 victims of attacks and clashes occurred.

In 1976 the status of political prisoner had been abolished , and the harsh conditions of imprisonment led to one of the most dramatic episodes of the Northern Irish conflict when, in 1981, 10 young Catholic militants led by Bobby Sands starved themselves to death in protest. 

A joint effort by the three major Northern Irish parties to discuss the reunification of the country (1983) was rejected by the British government. Instead, an Anglo-Irish agreement was reached in Hillsborough in 1985 , signed by M. Thatcher for England and G.

FitzGerald for I., which established an intergovernmental conference to discuss Irish political matters at regular intervals, giving the Republic of Ireland a consultative role in Northern Ireland matters. Although the agreement made it clear that the Northern Ireland constitution could not be changed without the assent of the majority of the population, violent protests came from the more hardline unionist camp. In February 1989, a consultative assembly was established to implement the agreement, made up of 50 MPs, half British and half Northern Irish.

 The latest developments of the conflict

In December 1993, the Downing Street Declaration was signed by the governments of Great Britain and Eire. This declaration launched a series of political proposals which, in their simplest terms, included:

  • The end of violence by paramilitary groups,
  • The recognition of the right of “separate self-determination” of North and South,
  • Dublin’s willingness to amend its constitution, where its claims to Northern Ireland are referred to, as part of a comprehensive political settlement.

On 31 August 1994, the IRA declared a ceasefire. On 13 October 1997, British Prime Minister Tony Blair met with Sinn Féin leader Gerry Addams at Stormont Castle, Belfast. This was the first meeting between a British Prime Minister and a Sinn Féin leader since David Lloyd George and Michael Collins signed the Anglo-Irish Treaty of 1921, which formally divided Ireland into two parts. This began negotiations that led to the signing of an agreement at Stormont on 10 April 1998 (the Good Friday Agreement ), promoted by the Irish and British governments. The agreement supersedes the one signed at Hillsborough.

 

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top