The desire to make a good impression and the fear of being rejected are experiences that all of us have in common. They are part of our genetic heritage and have an evolutionary explanation. Human beings, in fact, tend to seek acceptance and appreciation in order not to be rejected and rejected. This aspect, for our ancestors, would have jeopardized their survival. Living in a group was essential to help each other in hunting, in the care of the offspring and in defense from dangers. Our brain has therefore evolved identifying the possibility of being expelled, expelled or marginalized as a threat.
Also, as one grows, one learns that the closeness of the other must be earned by impressing him to be on his mind. These two aspects have therefore led man to guarantee survival by living in a group. Even if today being excluded does not put one’s life at risk, it is normal that everyone feels the need and gives great importance to being accepted by others .
When do we fear the judgment of others?
Anxiety experienced in circumstances in which we are judged by other people (e.g., college exam, job interview, first date, etc.) is a feeling we all know and are normal to experience. In fact, it has been widely demonstrated that a fair degree of anxiety, which is neither too high nor too low, motivates us to have optimal performance.
Sometimes, however, the fear of the judgment of the other emerges with high intensity, during the implementation of a performance (speaking in public) or during the normal actions of everyday life (entering a store to shop). Those who suffer from it experience a sense of oppression, which leads them to experience the feared situations with suffering or to avoid them completely.
Dysfunctional strategies to avoid the judgment of others
It is possible that, in addition to avoidance, there are other dysfunctional strategies used to manage this fear. For example, the use of alcohol , cannabis or anxiolytics produces a reduction in the levels of experienced anxiety . The person feels more comfortable in the situation and able to control it. These substances are used before facing the feared event, to reduce anticipatory anxiety . But also after the event to manage negative thoughts related to performance and performance anxiety . In addition to being harmful to health, once the effect is over, they lead the person to feel unable to act if not thanks to their use.
Furthermore, there are behaviors that protect against direct judgment. For example, hiding your face in your hands for fear of blushing, speaking quickly and as little as possible during a group discussion, agreeing with the other to avoid having to say your opinion. These are all counterproductive strategies that seem to help manage fear of judgment , but reinforce, in the long run, the idea of being inadequate in front of others.
Fear of other people’s judgment and psychiatric disorders
The fear of the other’s judgment is a central theme in social anxiety disorder . The person who suffers from it does not only suffer from shyness , but has a chronically feeling that the other will criticize and judge him. He feels constantly observed during performances or normal daily actions. There is also fear of the other person’s judgment in avoidant personality disorder , but these people struggle in a wide variety of contexts. Avoidants fear inclusion in the group and experience a sense of strangeness and exclusion that leads them to avoid any personal involvement.
The fear of the judgment of the other is transversal to numerous other disorders, even in those in which it seems that the other does not matter. In Narcissistic Personality Disorder , for example, contempt for other people hides a deep sense of inadequacy and a fear of not being appreciated. This is crucial for their self-esteem.
Finally, the mere fact of having a psychological or psychiatric problem can be a source of fear of the judgment of others. Mental illness, in fact, unlike the others, is still considered a taboo.
Treatment of the fear of judgment
The cognitive behavioral approach is the approach of choice to work on this problem. Usually, we start by evaluating the origins of this fear and the intensity of the discomfort. Then the thoughts underlying the fear of the judgment of others are made aware and they are taught to monitor them. Tools are provided to manage anticipatory anxiety (i.e. the emotional activation that emerges before facing the feared situation). Then we work with situational anxiety, through a series of techniques aimed at accepting the potential judgment of the other . Finally, the patient is gradually exposed to feared social situations. This favors the habituation of anxiety and helps decatastrophize what might happen.
A useful treatment to reduce fear of the judgment of the other therefore requires gradual exposure to feared situations. Normally, as such situations are faced, you gain confidence in your abilities and get used to the idea of being judged. In fact, a lot of therapeutic work is about being aware that rejection is not that dangerous. It is not a catastrophe and one can accept the possibility of not liking someone. All this does not pose a threat to our existence, indeed, it is important to be aware that rejection is a normal social event .
Useful tips to reduce the fear of others’ judgment
There are small strategies that we can independently implement in order to tolerate and accept the judgment of others :
- Avoidance is the main factor in maintaining this problem. It would therefore be useful to try to expose yourself to feared situationsthat do not create particular anxiety and to observe in a curious and open way what happens. If, for example, we are afraid to ask the barista to stain our coffee, we could do a little experiment to break our vicious circle. Being with the anxiety that this gesture causes us and accept it for what it is, just an emotion.
- When we find ourselves in a situation where we fear the judgment of the other, we tend to focus on our anxiety, on the negative judgment we have of ourselves or on how we might react (“I’ll go red, I’ll make a fool!”). Here too, starting from a not very threatening situation, the advice is to shift the attention focus outwards. For example by objectively describing what is around us, such as the sounds we hear, the colors we see, the shape of objects, etc.
- Loweringanticipatory emotional activation may also be helpful . When we know we are facing a feared situation, we can implement breathing exercises that help us lower the perceived level of anxiety, bringing our emotion back to a manageable level.
- Reading the other’s mind differently can help reduce fear of judgment. The goal of the exercise is to get used to the idea and accept the fact that we cannot know for sure the thoughts of others. It is therefore useful to take some time in a crowded place and ask yourself what tastes passersby may have in terms of food, what their passions are, where they are going. Already understanding that other people may have different tastes, opinions and thoughts than ours can soften the habit of attributing one’s mental states to those around us.
- Self-help readings on the subject (see below) are also useful, which serve as guidelines for putting the above advice into practice.
When to ask for professional help
When these tips don’t work and we recognize that we are overwhelmed with anxiety, then it is helpful to seek help from a professional psychotherapist. This can give us an explanation of why the judgment of the other is so important to us and then learn to acquire useful tools to break the vicious circles that maintain it.




