The psychological manipulation , as a means to exploit others in order to obtain from him a number of advantages for the more relational, can have endless nuances.
Sometimes, the consequences are serious or very serious for those who suffer the manipulation, so as to undermine their identity and emotional balance. Other times, however, the emotional manipulation within a relationship can even prove to be functional to the well-being of individuals or the relationship itself.
In fact, those who manipulate do not always do so with the awareness of compromising the relationship . He may also react with surprise or pain when confronted with the disastrous consequences of his actions.
Similarly, the manipulator is not always a perverse narcissist . Often he is a fragile person and distressed by the idea that he has to lie and alter reality in order to be wanted by someone. Instead, internally cultivates the belief that no one will be able to love her for what she really is.
How and where psychological manipulation occurs
Psychological manipulation can manifest itself as a transitory modality in ambiguous, suspended or evolving relational contexts. Courtship between two people can be a striking example. The courtship phase is one in which a sort of strategic manipulation is usually used, healthy within certain limits. That is, the ability to show the best parts of oneself to the other in order to hit and conquer him.
Still , the psychological manipulation can occur in all those relationships in which there has been an imbalance between the parties. As for example in the relationship between parents and children. In particular, it is assisted when adults feel the need to protect children from situations they could not understand and that would upset their balance.
Perhaps (because certainly not always true!) Certain omissions or distortions of reality can be interpreted by parents as “the lesser evil”, compared to the damage that according to them some truths could cause if not muffled by benevolent deceptions.
The benign and malignant manipulation
Manipulation, however, can also have more “malignant” characteristics. We could describe the different types of affective manipulation as if they were placed on a kind of continuum.
To understand psychological manipulation and its effects, it may be useful to imagine a continuous line, between two extremes. These include the various forms of relational manipulation, from harmless or even benign (“benign”) to those, instead, perverse (“malignant”).
Benign manipulations
The polarity of “benign manipulations” includes all those behaviors, attitudes and communications which, while distorting reality and information, have the purpose of arousing positive emotions in the other, or of protecting him in a situation of fragility.
To give a practical and very common example, the organization of a surprise birthday party will require the birthday party to ignore until the set day that all the guests will gather in secret to celebrate it. Technically, this is a great manipulation, but it is undoubtedly benign and orchestrated collectively and for good.
We all know well how even healthy affectivity is characterized by small deceptions, mostly motivated by the need to protect the other, look after him and create a stable and pleasant relational climate.
A distinctive element of “benign” manipulation, therefore, is that it does not in any case damage the values of trust and respect towards others. In these cases, the manipulator wants to provide something good to the other and, at the same time, wants to share his well-being and happiness.
It can be said that the positive end of the manipulation continuum includes all “relationship games” in which both participants somehow win.
Malignant manipulations
The opposite polarity, that is the “malignant” manipulation , is represented by the so-called gaslighting. Neologism introduced by American psychologists to designate the highest degree of cruelty, pathological Machiavellianism, emotional blackmail and relational violence.
The term is inspired by the 1944 film Gas Light , in which the adulterous protagonist persuades his wife that she is crazy in order to hide the betrayal from her.
The gaslighting is characterized by conscious actions, and calculated , targeted to confuse the perception of the victim and to demolish his self-esteem . This is in order to impose a psychological subjection, with the primary purpose of obtaining advantages to his detriment.
The “malignant” manipulator, or gaslighter , does not show empathy for his victim, nor does he stop before the dramatic consequences of his actions. Sometimes not even when the other loses control, to the point of believing himself crazy, to the point of perceiving his own identity as disintegrated.
The main objective of gaslighting , in fact, is precisely to undermine the autonomy and evaluative capacity of the other; to gain full control over his life.
Attacks are very often subtle, under-traced, not clearly recognizable either by the victim, nor by those around them. At other times they are explosive and aggressive and they use progressive devaluation, conditioning and silence . A pounding alternation, such as to destabilize even the most structured identities.
The strategies of the gaslighter
The progressive devaluation
To achieve the goal of progressively devaluing his victim, the “malignant” manipulator initially uses a slight irony (eg, on physical fitness or on the way of dressing, speaking, etc.).
Then it aims to criticize less and less covertly the victim’s habits, preferences, character traits, friends and family.
Finally, he devotes himself carefully and mercilessly to insinuating doubts about the morality of the other, about his loyalty, intelligence, honesty. He strikes one by one, like human skittles, all of her affective points of reference to lead her progressively to isolation , sometimes total.
The victim of the gaslighter will often not let him / her take the field, and will destroy the remaining bonds on their own. These in fact, due to mental manipulation, will appear to her as obstacles to be removed in order to conquer the “promised land” from her executioner.
The conditioning
Conditioning, on the other hand, consists of the controlled administration of small treats each time the victim appears exhausted and on the verge of collapsing. Or, better still, when he conforms to the malicious requests of the gasligther (e.g., a dinner, a few words of affection, an imperceptible hint of esteem, but above all sex).
In romantic relationships, which are the privileged place for this extreme manipulation, sexuality is administered as a narcotic . With a sort of meticulous and strategic attention. What the victim perceives as passion, as a total fusion with the other, by the gaslighter is instead used to define even more the sense of possession towards the other.
The manipulative silence
Silence, on the other hand, is the extreme punishment, the preferred strategy par excellence of the “malignant” manipulator. It consists in the total disavowal of the other, following what the executioner defines as very slight inconsistencies with his own claims.
The persecutor suddenly refuses all communication, manages to escape and, unlike the prey, can tolerate long periods of detachment. This is because he is aware that he only has to wait for the punishment to take effect.
In silence, the victim will tend to blame and feel sorry for having caused such a clear and incomprehensible break. Then it will come back weaker than ever. Moreover, if this does not happen, the gaslighting foresees that the manipulator will approach it again and shrewdly take advantage of the state of prostration in which he threw it, suddenly disappearing.
The pathological manipulator
Progressive devaluation, psychological conditioning and silence frame the “malignant” manipulation in its extreme form of gaslighting. At the same time, they identify the prevailing personological traits of the persecutor in pathological narcissism and sociopathy .
Knowing and learning to explore the manipulation continuum , between a “benign” and a “malignant” polarity of gaslighting can help us to clarify the differences between the various personality characteristics of manipulators. This is in order to identify certain characteristics within a relationship as soon as possible and ask for help immediately.
A more precise understanding of the dynamics triggered by the different types of manipulation can in fact favor the development of even more targeted psychotherapeutic treatments and support the victims in the process of release and recovery from a dysfunctional relationship in a shorter time.




