Debate is a conversation that involves two or more people in a problem & each expresses his opinion. In a debate there are usually parties who agree (pro) and those who disagree (cons) to a policy or problem being debated.
According to Widyamartaya to debate is to talk with the other party to defend or attack / opinion, collide intelligence and logic. In a general election contest, to argue means to clash intelligence and logic to discuss an electoral area problem by conveying the vision, mission, plans, programs and arguments of the candidates / debates.
According to Asidi Dipodjojo, debate is a process of oral communication conveyed through language in order to defend opinions. The parties to the debate will convey arguments and reasons in a certain way to the opposing party or the party who listens to the debate in order to convince all parties in the debate forum.
According to G. Sukadi defines the debate essentially the nature of arguing between individuals or groups of people, in order to achieve victory.
While the notion of discussion is a process that involves two or more people where between one another verbally interact and face each other, exchange information, defend each other’s opinion in solving certain problems.
At first glance the meaning of debate and discussion do not differ much, but specifically what distinguishes debate and discussion is
Characteristics of Debate and Discussion
| Debate | Discussion |
| Aim to get victory | Aims to find a solution to the topic together |
| Opinions / arguments are submitted to strengthen his opinion & drop the opinion of the opponent | Opinions / arguments expressed aim to get information to be more detailed |
| There are affirmative & negative parties | All in one party |
| Moderators function as mediators | The moderator is the controller of the discussion |
| There are limits in question and answer | There is openness in the question and answer session |
Purpose of the Debate
The debate forum is a good and strategic place to develop skills and hone skills in speaking. Debate also benefits human life. In addition to the following several objectives carried out debate on a forum:
-
- So that both parties are accustomed to try / build a case which is certainly supported by arguments in support of the case.
- Train people to be critical of all theories thrown.
- Train people in breaking opinions
- Improving one’s ability in terms of responding to a problem because here there is a process of mutually maintaining opinions between the two parties.
- Trainsomeone to be willing & brave to express their opinions.
Elements or Aspects in Debate
To create a debate forum must pay attention to aspects in the debate. The aspect in question is the theme of the debate, debate moderator, debate participants, listeners / audience and the time of the debate.
- Theme
Broadly speaking the theme is a problem or issue that will be discussed or developed in the debate. The theme is the subject of discussion in a debate, and therefore the theme must be chosen through various adjustments, so that the debate looks more alive. Themes should be conveyed before the debate is held.
The debate will be more interesting if the theme chosen is an interesting & actual problem or is actualized to be able to invite critical views & curiosity of the listener. In addition, the chosen theme should be able to evoke the intentions of the spirit of a person towards the thing or theme in question, first must be able to attract attention.
An interesting debate theme will generate interest and desire will emerge to find out the contents of the theme further
If the contents of the theme are known as a whole, then a decision will be taken, then move to take action Nayata as a manifestation of the decision maker.
- Moderator
The moderator is the guide or leader of the debate. As a leader, the moderator acts as a guide, mediates, or is like overseeing talk in a debate.
The task of a moderator in a debate can be said to be a tough task, namely to lead, to direct the course of the whole debate process. Apart from that a moderator must master the material being debated. Moderators must also be neutral, firm in upholding order, courtesy and discipline in using time.
However, in certain cases the moderator is also required to be able to be persuasive even if necessary it must be able to create a fresh atmosphere for example through healthy humor. In addition, a moderator must also have a strong personality in order to face the difficulties that often arise in the course of the debate.
- Participant
Is a person who takes a role and is directly involved in contributing ideas in a debate forum. Debate participants can be individuals or groups. Debate participants are usually divided into two groups, namely supporters and deniers. Usually the supporters have to submit negative suggestions or rebuttal of a theme content that is presented in the theme.
In debates, participants or speakers are tasked with convincing listeners through their proposals. In connection with this there are certain factors that must be known & owned by the debate participants as a speaker or communicator, as follows:
-
-
- Ethos
-
Ethos in communication are basic things that must be owned by a speaker so that it can be a source of trust for all who are present at the debate. This belief arises based on the character of a speaker. The character in question is authority, knowledge and commitment of the conversation to the theme of the conversation
-
-
- Pothos
-
Pothos in communication is the ability to speak in terms of conveying emotional appeals that can touch the feelings of the listener, for example through choosing the right words and sentences, varying tone of tone & so forth. Thus both consciously and unconsciously have made the listener on the speaker.
-
-
- Logos
-
If ethos is the ability possessed by a speaker in conveying an appeal, while logos is the ability of a speaker in terms of conveying a logical appeal in a proposal based on the results of thoughts that are constructive & incantation so that outside the thought the conversation can be digested & followed by the listener.
- Listener
In a debate forum, listeners can be from various groups, the listeners are required to pay attention to the course of debate actively, because at the end of the debate the listeners are usually asked to express their opinions or vote on the results of the debate. Therefore, listeners must be able to develop themselves to become good listeners including:
-
-
- Physical & mental state must be neutral, no pressure
- Develops curiosity & willingness to listen
- Pay attention to the speaker’s attitude
- Pay attention to how to use the speaker’s language
- Provide an assessment of the speaker’s mind, arguments and solutions proposed by the speaker and supporting facts
- Comparing similarities and differences between the results of the analysis presented by the speaker with the knowledge he has
-
- Time of debate
The organizers should design the allocation of debate time as needed, participants must be given sufficient opportunities to clearly explain their proposal. The elaboration of time allocation should be explained to the debate participants before the debate begins.
Types of Debates
Competitive debate
Is a type of debate in the form of a game that is usually done at the level of the can or university level. In this debate, it is done as a form of competition through clear and strict rules (format) between the two parties, each of which supports (pro) and opposes a statement (contra)
This debate is usually witnessed by one or more judges appointed to determine the winner of a debate. What emerged as the winners of competitive debates was the team that successfully demonstrated better debate knowledge & skills.
Parliamentary debate / assembly
It is a debate that aims to give data or add support to a particular law and all members who want to express their views & will also speak in support of or oppose the proposal after obtaining permission from the assembly
Debate re-examination to find out the truth of the previous examination ( cross-examination debating )
It is a debate that aims to raise a number of questions that are related to one another, which makes the individuals who are asked questions support the position to be upheld or strengthened by the questioner
Formal debate
It is a debate that provides an opportunity for both speakers to present to all listeners with a number of supporting arguments or those who refute a proposal. Each party will be given the same duration of time for both constructive and persistent speakers
Debate Structure
- Introduction stage
At this stage, each team (both the affirmation, the negative team and the neutral team) are all introduced.
- Submission of arguments
The next stage is to convey his arguments on the topic, starting from the affirmation team, the opposition to the neutral team
- Debate
Each team will be given the opportunity to make or comment on other teams.
Techniques And Tactics In Winning Debates
In winning a debate, of course preparations include mobilizing all the knowledge and intelligence of something that is acceptable so that the debate is beneficial for the implementation of the debate. The tactics meant in winning the debate are, tactics, intelligence, and the effort to achieve the goals & objectives of the debate through certain systems and methods.
Generally the techniques commonly used in debates consist of two kinds, according to the grouping, there are those who oppose as reinforcing proposals & there are those who oppose.
The technique of maintaining the proposal
Basically this technique can be done through:
-
-
- Affirmation tactics
-
This tactic is an affirmation of one item contained in it is repetition tactics, influence tactics, togetherness tactics, compromise tactics, agreed tactics & agreement tactics.
-
-
- Defense tactics
-
These tactics include, evasive tactics, delay tactics, destructive tactics, lifting tactics, thanksgiving tactics, describing tactics, elaborating tactics and letting tactics.
Techniques against the proposal
Can be reached through:
-
-
-
- Attack tactics, including questioning tactics, provocation tactics, anticipation tactics, surprising tactics, encompassing tactics, exaggerating tactics and cutting tactics
- Reject tactics, including criticism tactics & contradictory tactics.
-
-
The techniques and tactics above are an effective way to oversee the debate process.
Why is Debate Important?
The debate is important because it helps people develop skills that enable them to become more engaged citizens, discuss current political and global issues, understand conflicting views, work together with others, make right decisions and think critically. These skills are useful not only in the academic life of the community, but also in the workplace and in the community. according to the Boston Debate League, debates can also help people think more creatively and express themselves.
Debate Example
Is it important or not to use a school uniform?
“Pro”
-
-
-
- School uniforms make all students look the same. Poor and rich students have the same rights and obligations. With the uniform makes students more varied in their learning without having to think about differences between students.
- With a uniform, giving students a sense of belonging to the school
- Cheap and easy to clean school uniforms
-
-
“Kontra”
-
-
-
- School uniforms allow students not to be themselves. Students feel limited to expression. They also feel hot in summer and cold in winter, because their uniforms are not adapted to weather conditions.
- Students don’t need uniforms to be who they are.
- The price of school uniforms is quite expensive and easily broken.
-
-
How do you win a debate?
Debate is like an intellectual sport where you have to learn skills to win. For example, to win the debate round, you must have a full understanding of the topic in which you are debating. You should also be able to answer the following questions:
-
- Who are the people you are arguing with and who is arguing?
- What is the debate about?
- Where did the incident discussed occur?
- When did the incident discussed occur?
- Why did it happen and why did you argue about it?
- How did it happen?




