Feudalism is the economic and social formation established as a result of the decomposition and collapse of the slave regime or the primitive community regime ; it has existed in almost all countries [1] [2] .
Main classes
The main classes of feudal society were the feudal lords and the peasants . The dominant and exploiting class of lords included the nobility and the high clergy. Within the dominant class, there was a hierarchical division into estates, with the small feudal lords being subordinated to those of greater power.
The Church was a great feudal power. The exploited peasants had no political or legal rights. In the cities, the bulk of the population was made up of teachers, officials, apprentices and unskilled workers.
Production relations
The basis of the dominant production relations under feudalism was the feudal lord’s ownership of the means of production, primarily of the land, and the incomplete ownership of the worker, which was expressed in various types of personal dependence of the peasant on his lord.
Under feudalism, productive forces could only develop on the basis of the labor of dependent peasants, who owned their own land, insignificant instruments of labor, and felt some material interest in their work.
Feudal agrarian relations
Agricultural exploitation
The territories of the feudal lords contained not only a certain number of villages, but also a large number of towns. Therefore, both peasants and urban artisans were within their sphere of exploitation. Feudal property included complete ownership within a certain territory. The relations of agrarian property were firmly linked to the relations of personal dependence. Relations of personal dependence dominated the entire system of social relations in feudalism.
Agrarian and personal dependency relations
The most widespread and complete form of personal dependence of peasants on feudal lords was the so-called serfdom or right of serfdom.
The peasants’ subordinate relations to the feudal lords were manifested as relations between opposing classes, which pitted the direct producers against the exploiting classes. But the character of these relations was already different compared to slave society. The serf peasants were not the full property of the feudal lords. They could devote part of their time to their plot and to a certain extent were the owners of their shares. However difficult their situation was, the serfs exploited by the feudal lords were no longer their property and this proved to be a step forward compared to slavery.
The peasants owned means of production, agricultural implements, crafts, and livestock for rent and for work. The artisans of the city also owned means of production. The peasants and artisans also owned houses and outbuildings. Some means of production, such as wells, roads and sometimes pastures, were the property of the rural commune, which remained in certain territories despite the process of feudalization and, as a consequence, the subjugation of the peasants and the subordination of the community to the power of the feudal lords.
Feudal production and feudal rent
Feudal production developed in two main forms: in the form of a landlord economy and in the form of a tributary economy. Both forms had in common the following: a) the direct producer was personally dependent on the feudal lord; b) the feudal lord, on whom the direct producers were personally dependent, was considered the owner of all the land devoted to agricultural production; c) the direct producer had a plot of land which constituted his estate; d) the labour of the peasants was applied to agricultural production and their instruments of labour were used; e) the peasants invested additional labour and created additional product for the feudal lord as a result of extra-economic coercion.
Since the peasants possessed their own means of production necessary for independent management of the estate, the feudal lord could exploit the direct producer only by means of extra-economic coercion. “If the peasant did not have direct power over the person of the peasant,” wrote Lenin, “he could not force the man who owns the land in his own hands and has his own farm to work for himself.” The peasant farm formed the basis for the very existence of the peasant and his family. Unlike slavery, where the main source of labour power was war, the individual farm ensured a more or less regular reproduction of labour power.
Landed economy
In the landlord economy, the entire estate of the feudal lord was divided into two parts. One part was the landlord’s land, on which the peasants’ labour and tools produced agricultural products, which were entirely appropriated by the feudal lord. In this way, the additional labour of the peasants was invested on the landlord’s land and the additional product was obtained. The other part of the land was called the nadiel (lot). On this land the peasant had his farm, where he reproduced the necessary product. On this land he had to obtain enough product to feed himself and his family.
Tax economy
In the tributary economy, all land was given to the peasant as a sharecropper. All agricultural production was carried out on the peasant tributary farms. Part of the product created was given by the peasant to the landowner as tribute. The other part remained in the hands of the peasant for the reproduction of his labor force and the maintenance of his family.
Necessary and additional work
In the tributary economy, both additional and necessary labour were invested in the peasant’s estate. In the landlord economy, necessary labour and additional labour were separated in space and time: necessary labour was invested in the peasant’s estate and additional labour in the lands of the feudal lord (landlords).
In the tributary economy, necessary and additional labour were not separated, since the entire field of action was the peasant’s farm. But the necessary and additional products were separated from each other.
In the landlord economy, additional labour was delivered in its natural form, as a certain number of working days. In the tributary economy, additional labour was not delivered in its natural form, but in the form of the product of labour. Thus, the difference between the necessary product and the additional product was quite tangible: what the peasant gave to the feudal lord in the form of tribute was additional product. The part of the product that remained for him was necessary product. In the landlord economy, the difference between necessary labour and additional labour was also physically tangible.
Additional labour in the landlord economy differed little from the labour of slaves. The product of all labour in the landlord economy belonged to the feudal lord, so the peasant was not interested in its results. For this reason, the feudal lords converted the landlord estates into tax farms. The landowners faced objective limitations, since it was necessary to offer the peasants the opportunity to reproduce the necessary product. Otherwise, the peasant would not have been able to continue the production process.
On the other hand, the number of working days was not the same in all regions. In Russia, it had been legalized to three days, but later the landowners increased the number of working days until the peasants were only allowed to work on Sundays and evenings. This was detrimental to both the peasant and the landowner farms. The peasant lost all interest in the work of the landowner farm, and the productivity and quality of work decreased, which affected the additional product.
In a tribute-based economy, the landowner guaranteed himself a certain amount of additional product, which the direct producers (the peasants) were obliged to deliver to him. The increase in tribute met with resistance from the peasants. The history of feudalism is full of a sharp struggle of the peasants against the unlimited increase in the proportion of tribute.
The tribute consisted of certain products, which formed a set of use values produced by the peasants. Since the economy was generally of a natural character, the peasant had to produce the necessary product and the additional product on his farm. Later, the product in kind was supplemented by the tribute in money or was entirely replaced by money. In some feudal estates a mixed system was applied. In addition to personal service, the peasants owed tribute.
As can be deduced from the characterization of the landed economy and the tributary economy in the system of feudal economic relations, production was based on the peasant estate, which constituted the productive base of said mode of production.
Feudal production and extra-economic coercion
The basis of feudal exploitation was feudal land ownership in conjunction with personal dependence, which presupposed one or another form of extra-economic coercion. Without land ownership, the feudal lord would not have been able to exploit the peasants. In this sense, feudal land ownership was the basis of the feudal mode of production, but power over land was insufficient to exploit the peasant. The economy was organized in such a way that without relations of personal dependence and the possibility of extra-economic coercion connected with it, it would not have been possible to implement feudal economic relations. In this case, the peculiarity of the feudal mode of extra-economic coercion manifested itself as a necessary and obligatory condition of each individual estate. Therefore, the relations of dependence had a definite personal character.
Each individual peasant was the serf of a particular feudal lord. The objective necessity of extra-economic coercion was not sufficient to implement feudal relations of production. Without economic coercion, these relations would not have existed in their entirety, but extra-economic coercion alone was insufficient to make such economic relations effective. For this, feudal agrarian relations were necessary. In feudalism, the main means of labour was the land, and agrarian relations were the determining relations. Feudal ownership of land presupposed as its essential characteristic that the direct process of production was carried out by the peasants, who inevitably owned land, which was the basis of their tributary estate. In the landlord economy, the basis of the peasant estate was a part of the land of the feudal lord’s domain, and in the tributary economy, the entire land was the basis of the peasant estate.
Forms of feudal rent
Agrarian relations constituted the fundamental relations of production in the feudal system. Thus, the fundamental relations of production in feudalism were expressed in rent, which represented the economic form of realization of feudal ownership of land.
Additional labour and additional product were expressed in the form of rent under the conditions of the feudal mode of production. Depending on the character and form of appropriation of additional labour and additional product, the following types of rent existed. In the landlord economy, additional labour was obtained through coercing the dependent peasant to work on the landlord’s land. Such a form of additional labour was expressed in the form of labour rent. In the tributary economy, when the feudal lord determined which products were to be paid to him as tribute, the additional labour was appropriated by the feudal lord through the product as additional product. Such a form of feudal rent was called product rent. If the amount of tribute was set in money, the additional labour was not appropriated by the feudal lord in the form of labour, nor in the form of the product of labour, but as a certain amount of value paid in money. The transition to income in money was the result of the increase in the division of labor, which gave rise to the exchange and gradual diffusion of mercantile monetary relations in society.
Fundamental economic law
The purpose of feudal production was to create an additional product, which was appropriated by the feudal lords in the form of ground rent and used to satisfy their needs. The original duality of the labour of the dependent peasants determined the duality of the additional product in feudal society. The additional product, like the necessary product, was a use value, that is, it was capable of satisfying the needs of those who appropriated it, i.e., the feudal lords, by virtue of their status as landowners. At the same time, having been created by the forced labour of the serf peasants, the additional product took the specific form of feudal ground rent. The additional product created as a result of the forced labour of the dependent peasants of the feudal lords was appropriated by the latter in the form of feudal ground rent for their parasitic consumption. This is the essence of the fundamental economic law of feudalism.
Feudal reproduction
In the landlord economy and in the tributary economy, the peasant had everything necessary for the maintenance of his farm, since he was not interested in establishing any kind of economic relations with the class of feudal lords, since the latter only consumed in a parasitic way the additional work and the additional product created by him. If the class of landlords (the feudal lords) had disappeared as a result of historical circumstances, peasant farms would not have been deprived of the economic conditions for their reproduction. On the other hand, the peasants would have been freed from handing over the additional work to the feudal landlord. Therefore, in order for reproduction to take place on a feudal basis, extra-economic coercion was necessary.
In feudalism, the volume of production grew slowly over whole generations. The needs of the direct producers and their relatives grew very slowly. Only in a few situations did the extended reproduction take place, which was atypical for this type of economic relations, and it was not an uninterrupted process. Parasitic consumption was the driving force of feudal production. The feudal lords did not use the product they produced to increase production. Extended reproduction presupposes the expansion of the production not only of the additional product, but of all the conditions of the production process: of the means of production and of the necessary product. Therefore, if extended reproduction were to take place on the landed estate, it was only the increase in the production of the additional product.
Reproduction on the peasant farm was of a decisive nature. The work of serf peasants reproduced not only the products intended to satisfy the needs of the feudal lords and the producers themselves and their families, but also the conditions for the continuation of the production process on their farm. The peasants had to carry out work that ensured the continuity of production.
The increase in production on peasant farms was necessarily limited by the fact that as production increased, the rents that had to be paid increased. On the other hand, in order to pay the increased rent, the producer had to maintain the expanded production.
The source of every increase in production is the additional product. Therefore, it could only take place if a part of the additional product was occasionally used to expand and improve production, which was not common due to the parasitic consumption of the feudal class. This occurred sporadically, preferably on occasions when, due to the existence of previously fixed benefits, the feudal lord could not appropriate all at once the result of the increase in the productivity of labour on the peasant farm.
Development of productive forces
Feudal relations of production contributed to the further development of productive forces over a certain historical period. The most significant changes in the development of productive forces occurred in the 15th and 16th centuries due to progress in the iron and steel industry, metalworking and energy.
In the second half of the 15th century, blast furnaces began to be used for iron smelting, which increased labour productivity in the iron and steel industry and increased the production of ferrous metals. Metal hammers driven by a hydraulic flywheel began to be used for forging metal. Simple types of lathes, drills and grinding machines also appeared. This created the conditions for perfecting work tools in all spheres of the economy.
New mechanisms (water pumps, hoists, etc.) were used for mining, which made it possible to extract useful minerals from mines located at great depths. Wind motors and the hydraulic flywheel were perfected and became widely used. Mechanical clocks became known in the 12th century, and the first automatic mechanism, the wind-up pocket watch, was built at the end of the 15th century. The printing press was discovered and spread. Important changes took place in ship building and navigation technology.
Some technical progress was made in agriculture, the arable land area increased and the volume of agricultural production grew.
Development of commercial relations
In parallel with the development of technology, the social division of labour increased, especially in the field of crafts. More and more craftsmen were created who specialised in the production of a few goods. Various crafts that peasants had been engaged in in their homes and on the estates of landowners (spinning, weaving, etc.) became independent branches. As a result of the growth of the social division of labour, the production and exchange of commodities inevitably increased.
In the late 15th and early 16th centuries, the money form of rent became dominant in a number of countries, which considerably expanded commodity and monetary relations and the influence of the market in the feudal economy. The isolation of peasant and landowner estates gradually disappeared. Peasants gradually became commodity producers. Commodity relations expanded more rapidly in the towns because the division of labour and specialisation of production changed more rapidly than in the countryside. The further development of towns as centres of commodity production and trade had an ever greater influence on the disintegration of the natural economy.
The increase in commercial production was accompanied by the expansion of the market. Trade relations between cities and between cities and the countryside, as well as between different countries, became increasingly extensive and necessary. The great geographical discoveries gave a strong impetus to the development of trade.
Disintegration of the natural economy
In the 15th and 16th centuries, commercial and monetary relations had sufficiently penetrated the economy not only of the cities, but also of the countryside. The existence of artisan guilds and natural estates under these conditions became increasingly incompatible with the needs of the subsequent development of the economy.
The feudal organization of craft production in the form of a guild system, with its strict regulation of the volume and technology of production and the monopoly of guild production, limited the possibilities for significant progress in production technology and for increasing the quantity of commodity production.
Feudal agriculture, with the fragmentation of the lands of small producers and the forced rotation of crops within the boundaries of the community subject to the feudal lord, prevented the increase in labor productivity and the expansion of the estate.
At the same time, the natural economy, with its production for itself, hampered the scale of the internal market and hindered the development of the exchange of goods. Feudal relations hindered the flow of labour into the towns, without which the market could not expand. Artisans and peasants were kept in the system of feudal production by means of extra-economic coercion, and even people who had accumulated considerable wealth (merchants, usurers and wealthy artisans) could not really organise large-scale production in town or in the countryside, because they did not have sufficient labour power. In this situation, the feudal method of uniting labour power with the means of production was increasingly inadequate to the development of productive forces.
An irreconcilable contradiction arose between the new productive forces, which required new forms of organisation of labour in the form of cooperation between specialised producers and a new method of uniting labour power with the means of production, on the one hand, and the outmoded relations of production based on the personal dependence of producers on the landowners, on the other hand. There arose a social need to replace the old feudal relations of production with new ones, which would correspond to the growing development of the productive forces.
Differentiation of commodity producers
As the social division of labour expanded and the sphere of commodity and monetary relations expanded, the patrimonial and social differentiation of the direct producers of commodities increased. Since the productivity of individual labour was not equal, commodity producers invested different amounts of labour in the production of the same commodity.
Commodity producers who had worse conditions of production, invested much more labour and could only partially cover their production costs by selling their commodities. Inexorably, some of these producers went bankrupt. On the other hand, those who enjoyed better conditions of production and achieved a higher intensity and productivity of labour became richer. They accumulated large sums of money and means of production. This created the conditions for a new process of uniting producers with means of production. The bankrupt commodity producers, lacking all means of production, were forced to hire themselves out for money, working for those who owned the means of production. Commodity production based on the means of production and the labour of the producers themselves was increasingly transformed into a new, more developed form of commodity production: the capitalist form of commodity production.
Emergence of capitalist commodity production
The capitalist relations of production that emerged within the feudal system differed from the previous forms of the commodity economy, above all as large-scale production that employed the cooperation of the work of many wage workers.
In the process of the emergence and development of the capitalist mode of production, merchant capital and usury capital played a leading role, as they provided an incentive for the development of commodity-money relations. Merchant capital that had been created earlier was often invested in industry, and merchants then became manufacturing capitalists. Sometimes usurers became bankers. Neither merchant capital nor usury capital could by themselves bring about a radical revolution in production relations; they only helped to create the conditions for the emergence of capitalist forms of production.
The consolidation of capitalist relations of production meant the transformation of the mass of producers into proletarians, free from all personal dependence but at the same time deprived of all means of production. On the other hand, the concentration of wealth in money and the means of production in the hands of a minority. In the creation of these conditions lies the essence of the so-called primitive accumulation of capital. On this subject, Marx wrote: “The system of capital presupposes the divorce between the workers and the property over the conditions of their work…Therefore, the process which produces capitalism can only be one: the process of dissociation between the worker and the property over the conditions of his work, a process which on the one hand converts the social means of life and production into capital, while on the other hand converts the direct producers into wage-workers. So-called primitive accumulation is therefore nothing other than the historical process of dissociation between the producer and the means of production.”
The process of the original accumulation of capital constitutes the prehistory of capitalism and preceded the consolidation of capitalism as the dominant mode of production.
Role of violence in the establishment of capitalism
The bourgeois economists sublimely describe the history of the emergence of capitalism, claiming that the accumulation of wealth began in ancient times as a result of the love of work and the spirit of austerity of some and the indolence and waste of others. In truth, capitalist relations of production arose and later became objectively the dominant relations, as a result of the laws of social development. But the original accumulation of capital was aided and accelerated by the use of direct and undisguised violence of any kind.
A typical example of the development of the primitive accumulation of capital is the events of the 16th and 17th centuries in England, where capitalist production reached a higher level of development earlier than in other European countries. The bourgeois nobility violently evicted the peasants who had freed themselves from feudal serfdom from the land. Landless, the peasants were forced to hire themselves out to the capitalists. At the same time, the capitalist farmers emerged. “The memory of this crusade of expropriation,” wrote Marx, “has been inscribed in the annals of history with indelible traces of blood and fire.” The ruined and landless peasants gradually became an impoverished mass, filling the roads and towns in search of work and means of subsistence. Thus, through violence, the proletarianization of the broad masses was accelerated.
Violence is also an important means of accelerating the concentration of wealth in the hands of a few. Many capitalist enterprises were born at the expense of the accumulation concentrated in the hands of merchants and usurers. But other methods of wealth accumulation also played an enormous role, such as the system of colonial exploitation of peoples, trade with the colonies, including the slave trade, trade wars, the system of state loans and taxes, and the protectionist tariff policy of the state.
Thus, through the dispossession and ruin imposed by violence on the mass of small producers and the rigorous oppression of colonial peoples, the creation of the conditions for the domination of capitalist relations of production was accelerated.
Sharpening of the class struggle
The disintegration of the feudal system took place in accordance with the objective laws of social development. This process was accelerated by the use of large-scale violence as a method of primitive accumulation of capital. The basis of feudalism was increasingly weakened by the effects of the increasingly sharp class struggle, manifested in the actions of the mass of peasants against the oppressors.
In the 14th century there was the English peasant uprising led by Wat Tyler and the French peasant revolt (Jacquerie). In the 15th century peasant revolts broke out in Bohemia led by Jan Hus. In the 16th century in Germany there were major peasant actions led by Thomas Munzer.
The peasant uprisings were the prelude to the bourgeois revolutions. The peasants and artisans were the main driving forces of the bourgeois revolutions. But the fruits of their struggles and victories were seized by the bourgeoisie, which seized state power. The first bourgeois revolutions occurred in the Netherlands (16th century) and in England (17th century). The French Revolution , which began in 1789 , was of enormous importance for the overthrow of the rule of the feudal lords and the triumph of the bourgeoisie in Europe. The bourgeois revolutions dealt the final blow to the feudal system and consolidated the new mode of production: the capitalist mode of production.
Vestiges of feudalism today
Many centuries have passed since the disappearance of feudalism in many countries, but its vestiges still exist in the developed capitalist world of today. In Italy, which is highly capitalist, there are still large noble estates, which cover more than 10% of the country’s arable land. The system of sharecropping is widespread there, whereby part of the harvest is given to the landowner as ground rent.
There are traces of feudalism in other developed capitalist countries of Europe ; and they are very clear in the economies of certain countries of Latin America , Asia and Africa . In Brazil, for example, 177 million hectares belong to large estates. The predominant form of land renting is semi-feudal sharecropping.In Iran, where half of the land belongs to large landowners and renting on the basis of the sharecropping principle is widespread, agrarian relations have a semi-feudal character.In Türkiye, large landowners own more than a third of the arable land.
One of the most significant problems in the development of many peoples is to definitively suppress the vestiges of feudalism. These can only be eliminated in colonial and underdeveloped countries by increasing their liberation struggle.

