In relation to humans, “race” is a controversial term for many biologists and non-biologists. While in English and French “race” often simply refers to a group of people or the whole of humanity (“human race”), without the intention of classifying or profound differences, “Rasse” in German stands for groups of people who genetic diversity should be defined. In the dispute over this concept of race, there is no biological question that there are genetically determined differences between people . However, it is questionable whether the biological concept of race and the categories associated with it are suitable for adequately capturing the apparent diversity of humans.
In the sense of the zoological system , all people living today form a single species . Members of all populations can mate with one another in an indefinitely fertile manner ( reproduction , fertility , sexual reproduction ).
The term race is rarely used in zoology. It is almost completely replaced by the term subspecies ( trinary nomenclature ). The division of diverse species into subspecies often causes difficulties, even with animals, and is associated with arbitrary decisions. As with other species, attempts have been made to distinguish between subspecies or races with Homo sapiens . According to the zoological nomenclature , this is neither biologically required for other living beings nor for humans, that is, there is no regulation below the species Taxa ( Taxon) to build. There is a clear reason for this in the living beings themselves: every organism that reproduces biparentally inevitably belongs to a reproductive community , and thus to a biological species is to be assessed very differently according to the ascertainable population differentiation.
There are nearly as many racial classifications in humans as there are scientists who have studied the problem. The number of different “races” ranges from 3 to over 200.
Much of the traits traditionally used to classify human races appear to offer a selective advantage under certain conditions. They are features of the body surface that were formed relatively recently under the respective environmental conditions (surface features). The pigmentation of the skin depends on the average exposure to UV light ( skin color , ultraviolet ), the relationship between body surface and volume is related to thermoregulation ( temperature regulation ), the curly hair ( hair [Fig.]) Acts as an air cushion to protect the braininterpreted against overheating (»natural tropical helmet«; hair coat ), the crease of the eyelid ( Mongolian crease ) as protection from light, snow, sand, etc. Further differences in characteristics (lip width, eye shape [ facial attractiveness ], body shape ) could be developed through »sexual selection« his. Selection- related characteristics are unsuitable for indicating genetic relationship , as they, like the dark skin tone in the equatorial areas of all continents, can be developed in parallel (functional similarity : convergence ; race genesis). The characteristics and combinations of characteristics recorded in this way are caused by many genes and environmental factors, so that their genetic basis is still unclear today ( polygeny ).
Molecular biological methods , on the other hand, allow DNA sequences ( sequencing ), genes ( gene ) and monogenic characteristics ( monogenic characteristics ) to be recorded directly. Such methods ( molecular genetics , biochemistry ) include, among other things, the analysis of the variability and coupling of point mutations (single nucleotide polymorphism, SNP ), the sequence analysis of individual sections of the nuclear DNA ( deoxyribonucleic acids ), in particular little or no recombining sequences of the Y chromosome and the X chromosome, highly variable DNA regions or entire genomes of mitochondria ( chondroma ) as well as the comparative investigation of chromosome structures ( chromosomes ). In this case, selection-neutral characteristics are preferably taken into account, for example sequences of non-coding DNA ( gene mosaic structure , processing ). The results, together with the statistical analysis ( statistics ) of the geographical distribution of allele frequency ( allele frequency out) Mendelian features into a new picture of human diversity and the history of human populations (including L. Cavalli-Sforza, B. Sykes, AR Templeton) .
According to the criteria used in zoology for classification are subspecies
- geographically limited, clearly differentiated populations;
- tribal lines separated for a long time.
According to the results of evolutionary biology and molecular genetic research, the two criteria do not apply to human populations. The race systematics are therefore not confirmed. This even applies to the division into so-called geographical large races and their alleged formation in Ice Age isolates. In short: the differences between the geographical groups are small, the differences change continuously with the geographical distance, the differences between the groups are smaller than those between the individuals within the respective geographical groups. No separate tribal lines (over a long period of time) can be distinguished. Instead, there is a genetic network that connects all populations (see below). The traditional race concept is to be abandoned in favor of a historical and dynamic view of human diversity ( see Infobox ; UNESCO statement).
Opinion on the race question
The revolution in how we think about population genetics and molecular genetics has resulted in an explosion of knowledge about living things. The concepts of human variation are among the ideas that have changed profoundly. The concept of “race” carried over from the past into the 20th century has become completely obsolete. Regardless, this concept has been used to justify wholly unacceptable violations of human rights. An important step in preventing such misuse of genetic arguments is to replace the outdated concept of “race” with ideas and inferences based on a valid understanding of genetic variation appropriate to human populations.
“Races” of humans are traditionally viewed as genetically uniform but different from one another. This definition was developed to describe human diversity, such as that associated with different geographic locations. However, recent advances in modern biology based on the methods of molecular genetics and mathematical models of population genetics show that this definition is completely inadequate. The new scientific evidence does not support the earlier view that human populations could be classified into separate “races” such as “Africans”, “Eurasians” (including “Native Americans”), or any greater number of subgroups. …
This document emphasizes that there is no scientifically reliable way to characterize human diversity in the rigid terms of “racial” categories or the traditional concept of “race”. There is no scientific reason to continue using the term “race”.
(Scientific working group of the international UNESCO conference “Against Racism, Violence and Discrimination” on June 8th and 9th, 1995 in Stadtschlaining, Austria)
Attempts at “race classification”
The “father” of biological systematics, C. von Linné , not only arranged humans in an order with the apes , but also distinguished 4 geographical “varieties” (americanus, europaeus, asiaticus, afer) in 1740, which he typified – contrary to the known range of variation – attributed different skin colors (red, white, yellow, black). In 1775, F. Blumenbach derived three ideal types from comparisons of skulls (African, Caucasian, Mongolian), between which he added two intermediate forms (Malay and Indian). Although from cranial skeletons ( skull), Blumenbach’s classification with the characterization by the assigned skin colors became popular: “black”, “brown”, “white”, “red” and “yellow”. Another well-known attempt at classifying races, which Germany has often followed in scientific and popular literature to this day, is that by E. von Eickstedt (1934) with 3 geographical “large races” ( Europide , Mongolide , Negride ) and numerous regional “races” and “sub-races” ( see Table 1 ). As in all older experiments, the classification was typologically based primarily on methods of descriptive or measuring morphology ( anthropometry).
Tab. 1: Classification of human races according to von Eickstedt (1934)
| CAUCASIAN | |
| Blond breed belt | Nordide, Teutonordide, Dalofaelide, Fennonordide, Eastern European |
| Brown race belt | Mediterranide, Grazilmediterranide, Eurafrikanide, Berberide, Orientalide, Indide, Grazilindide, Nordindide, Indobrachide, Pazifide, Polyneside, Microneside |
| Mountain ridge belt | Alpinide, Westalpinide, Lappide, Dinaride, Armenide, Turanide, Aralide, Pamiride |
| Old European | Weddide, Wedda, Gondide, Malide, Toalide, Ostweddide, Ainuide |
| MONGOLIDS | |
| Polar belt | Sibiride, West Siberide, East Siberide, Eskimide |
| North Mongolide | Tungide, Sinide, North Sinide, Middle Sinide, South Sinide |
| South Mongolid | Palämongolide, Palaungide, Neside |
| Indianide | |
| North Indianide | Pazifide, Zentralide, Silvide, Planide, Appalacide, Margide |
| South Indianide | Andide, Patagonide, Brasilide, Lagide, Fuegide, Südfuegide, Huarpide |
| NEGRIDE | |
| Contact belt | Ethiopids, North Ethiopids, East Ethiopids, Central Ethiopids, Indomelanids, South Melanids, North Melanids |
| West Negro | Sudanide, Nilotide, Kafride, Palänegride |
| Eastern Negroid | Neomelaneside, Palämelaneside, Australide |
| Khoisanids | Khoisanide, Khoide, Sanide |
| Pygmids | Bambutide, Negritide, Aetide, Semangide, Andamanide |
Eickstedt also used exact measuring methods, but believed that “race” could also be perceived directly, through the “type inspection” of the experienced scientist. With the “Eickstedtian race formulas” he believed that he could determine the mixed proportions of races (eg “Nordide” and “Osteuropide”) in the individual and in this way determine the percentage of “racial proportions” in the population. “Race” was assumed to be an enduring quantity that was not destroyed by the recombination of genes during reproduction. The aim was to encompass human races as “zoological groups of forms” both in terms of morphology and behaviorto describe. The distinction between races was thus closely linked from the start with statements about psychological and cultural characteristics that were understood as “race-typical” (see below: Race and Culture).
The typological approach corresponded to the idea that the “large races” were formed in 3 isolates (so-called breeding areas) through mutation and selection . Therefore, it has also tried to fossils of Homo sapiens classified as races. Today, however, these are interpreted as variants within the fossil populations ( Aurignacide , Cromagnide ).
As early as the 1930s, the population genetic analysis ( population genetics ) brought the diversity of populations and the transitions between them more into focus. In Germany this view only came into play after 1945. It was also reinforced by biochemical characteristics (above all of the blood proteins ; cf. Tab. 2 ) with which genetic differences between the populations could be described as the frequency distribution of the underlying alleles ( blood groups [Tab.]). Accordingly, “geographical races” were defined as populations that differ from others in the frequency of certain alleles (according to T. Dobzhansky). The typology remained in play, in that the diversity in the populations , which was actually already covered in its range of variation ( variation ), was reduced to so-called population-typical characteristics. This in turn should make a scientific race system possible. The questionable nature of this project becomes apparent when not only the “focal points” of the geographical feature formation, but also the “gradations between them” are to be classified as separate races (according to R. Knussmann). Transitions are eliminated here through »taxonomic racial segregation«. In this way a multitude of “races” and “sub-races” continues to be constructed, to which there is no parallel in the zoological system.
Smooth transitions and genetic closeness
The eye-catching differences between people, such as pigmentation (skin color, hair color, eye color), hair shape and face shape ( face , head ) are caused by only a few alleles and are geographically largely connected by smooth transitions ( human races II ). People living today agree 99.9 percent in their DNA sequences. All conceivable genetic differences therefore only affect 1 per thousand of the genetic substance. It is noteworthy that humans differ from one another in genetic terms much less than chimpanzees, for example. While chimpanzees of different geographical origins are phenotypically (phenotype) hardly different from each other, so that even specialists cannot assign individuals to one of the geographical subspecies, the genetic differences between them are about 10 times greater than those between humans ( human races II ).
Human races II
Differences between human populations can indeed be recorded statistically, but they are either too small or too insignificant to be able to differentiate between subspecies (“races”) according to the standards of the zoological system. Statistically significant genetic differences can be found between European and Asian populations, but also between North Germans and South Germans or even between the populations of different parts of the city in the same city. The variability changes largely continuously: The genetic distances between the populations are highly correlated ( correlation ) with the geographical distance in which they live today ( see Fig. 1 ).
Fig. 1 | Genetic distances and isolation through geographical distance. The genetic distances between populations on earth are plotted as a function of their geographical distances. The points correspond to collected data; the dashed curve indicates the theoretical values that are to be expected in the case of isolation by geographical distance.
The variation of gene sequences ( nucleotide sequence ) connects all continents with one another ( human races I ). Genetic marker , for example, the Human Genome Project ( Genome Project , Human Genome Diversity Project ) have been discovered and are, indeed possible to determine the geographical origin of individuals. But they say just as little about the other genome of the examined person as a morphological feature, e.g. the strength of the skin pigmentation. The visible differences between people of different geographic origins can appear large and significant because they are surface featuresparticularly noticeable. However, geographically neighboring populations are genetically closer than geographically more distant populations even if their representatives look very different ( human races I )). The typological differences based on surface features say little or nothing about the genetic proximity or distance of people: “Race does not get under the skin” (R. Lewontin).
Human races I
Diversity within the groups
Saying goodbye to the concept of race does not mean denying genetic differences between people. However, the racial concept proves to be unsuitable for capturing these adequately. Most of the genetic differences are not to be found between the geographical groups, but between the individuals of the same population ( see Fig. 2 ). The detection of haplotypes of the mitochondria and the Y chromosome also allows the origin of the paternal and maternal lines in a population to be differentiated. It turns out that – with the possible exception of small isolates ( inbreeding ) – no population represents a genetic unit, but a dynamic genetic networkof lines of different origins. Sometimes different geographical origins of the most common maternal (mitochondrial) and paternal (Y-chromosomal) lines can be detected, such as European or Asian lines in Finns, African or European mitochondrial or Y-chromosomal lines in Ethiopians.
Fig. 2 | Genetic differences between individuals and populations. A maximum of 25% of the human genes are variable: There are several alleles of the same gene location. The genetic differences based on different alleles or allele distributions predominantly exist between the individuals of the same population. Compared to the individual differences, those between the populations are negligible: the differences between the geographical groups (“races”) are only about 10% of all differences.
With so-called racial mixing , nothing else happens than with couples of the same geographical origin: Children are always conceived by genetically different people. The fact that surface features are perceived as essential differences by people of different geographical origins is based on socio-psychological judgments and not on genetic differences:
“What unites us are genes – what divides us are prejudices”
(H. Seidler)
Population history
Whatever one understood by “races”, they were never something constant or even a unity that had to be preserved. “Types and taxa only exist in thoughts, only individuals and their diversity are really present” (E. Mayr ). Types ( type ) are static imaginary constructs. The racial typology corresponds to this, in that “races” are viewed as groups that have been adapted to the respective environment and that have been bred out through selection. This one-sided selectionist view is aimed at the preservation of the races and regards them as something permanent. In the light of evolution , on the other hand, the dynamics of populations that cause rapid change ( population dynamics) in the foreground: The genetic differences in the allele distributions were and are only snapshots in the history of the population. From today’s perspective, therefore, they are tools in an effort to reconstruct the history of human populations. The results of molecular genetic research do not point to a “breeding” of “races” in isolated isolates, but to the spread of populations, migrations and repeated colonization of residential areas. In addition to mutation and selection , the main causes of genetic differences between the populations are allele drift and allele flow ( gene flow) played a crucial role. For population differentiation, separation by geographic distance ( isolation-by-distance ) has obviously played a greater role than geographic barriers ( separation ). This corresponds to the continuous variation depending on the geographical distance ( see Fig. 1 ). Variants of gene sequences can be found distributed across the continents. Accordingly, diagrams for genetic distances are not to be interpreted as classifications or phylogenetically as splits ( human races I ). Unlike in family trees ( family tree) the lines in the diagram do not symbolize separate tribal lines. The representation as subdivisions is rather methodologically determined: in the dendrogram only the relative distances are shown, but not the relationships and interactions between the lines. The dendrogram does not record whether the genetic distances are the result of temporary separation and subsequent mixing or whether there was a more or less large gene flow between the populations. The great genetic proximity between humans and the patterns of genetic variability ( human races II ) suggest that phases of genetic separation between the populations throughout the population history of the species Homo sapienswere insignificant. The breakdowns in the diagram are to be interpreted in terms of population history as evidence of migrations and settlements in the various geographic regions ( see Fig. 3 ).
Fig. 3 | Emigration of Homo sapiens from Africa. DNA analyzes indicate that modern humans originated in East Africa about 200,000 (130,000 to 465,000) years ago and members of this species emigrated from Africa 100,000 years ago. The assumed hiking trails are consistent with the dating of fossil evidence on the various continents (figures in years before our time). Main hiking trails to South Asia and America can also have run along the coasts.
After all fossil documents and according to the closest phylogenetic relationship with the African apes ( chimpanzee , bonobo , gorilla ) is considered safe, that the genus Homo in Africa has arisen ( Hominids , Paläanthropologie ). Accordingly, all people living today are the descendants of immigrants from Africa. Those variants of gene sequences that can only be found on other continents are modifications of those that occur in Africa ( Human Races II ). In Europe 95% of the population can be traced back to 7 mitochondrial types of Africans and thus genealogically to 7 maternal African lines (B. Sykes).
The genetic distances of the populations ( human races I ) document the emigration from Africa, the settlement of the continents and new residential areas as well as the associated processes of allele drift and allele flux. The latter factor can also be seen as the cause of the greater genetic proximity of Europeans to Africans compared to Asians.
According to the out-of-Africa model , the emigration of our ancestors began around 100,000 years ago, according to the multiregional modelalready about 2 million years ago. The greatest genetic variability in African populations, the close relationship between the rest of the population and the Africans, and the great genetic proximity of all people living today support the first hypothesis. For the second, it must be assumed that allele flow between populations has existed over great geographical distances for about 2 million years. The established genetic proximity of human populations would not be affected if the multiregional hypothesis finally turned out to be probable. Only the date of emigration from Africa would change.
“Whether we like it or not: Basically we are all Africans”
(U. Kattmann)
“Race” and Culture
People often judge and evaluate each other according to their group membership ( group , group identity , group norms , intolerance , prejudice , xenophobia ). “Race” is therefore also and above all a social-psychological phenomenon . Especially in biological anthropology , which is understood scientifically , the classifications of races were associated with social evaluation from the start. As early as 1740 Linnaeus provided the geographical varieties he distinguished with psychological and cultural attributes.
Concepts of superior and inferior races pervade racial studies in the 19th and 20th centuries. Above all, the skin tones reduced to a few color qualities in the typology were associated with psychological properties via the color symbolism (e.g. black and white as “bad” and “good”). The intention of a comprehensive zoological description was shaped by traditional ideas of this science. The scale of beings ( Scala naturae ), which was adopted from medieval theology in secular modern science, played an important role. It is expressed in the division into “higher” and “lower” living beings and also contributed to the notions of higher developmentand evolutionary progress. Applied to humans, it led to the distinction between older and younger “racial classes”, which were equated with “primitive” and “progressive”. In Eickstedt’s work, the idea of the layering and displacement of the “primitives” by the progressive, civilized “races” is the guiding principle. Primitive “races” are accordingly often pushed into inhospitable retreats and are sometimes characterized by childlike and animal characteristics. Eickstedt accordingly characterized “pedomorphic” and “theromorphic” races, which in his opinion should represent the “old classes” of the “Mongolids” and the “Negrids”. In a similar way, the “races of the German people” were characterized not only morphologically but also mentally (e.g. “Nordic” character destined to rule, “Eastern” to submission). The human geneticist F.Lenz , who was critical of the morphological racial classifications, instead saw the core of the racial question in the psychological and defined in the leading textbook of the time (“Outline of human heredity and racial hygiene”; E. Baur , Eugen Fischer , F. Lenz, 1936) the ” Jews “as a” soul race “that was bred out under the conditions of the ghetto.
Essential elements of the connection between “race” and culture were, in addition to the assumption of psychological racial characteristics, the postulate of different cultural abilities of races, the conception of races as variables that encompass and outlast individuals, and consequently the requirement of “racial unity” and the conviction of Harmfulness of “racial mixtures”. Through these concepts, biological race science was closely linked to socially and politically motivated race teachings. The supposedly scientifically based racial classifications were therefore always guided by social discrimination and group egoistic interests ( Racism). Socially determined ideas about race continue to contribute to the persistence of the concept of race in biology, in that social groups are mistakenly understood as biologically defined “races” (eg the “blacks” in the USA). Scientifically oriented racial studies and ideological racial ideologies can hardly be separated in their history of impact. The latter became “racial theories” with philosophical and political claimsformulated with which it was attempted to interpret the course of history as a result of racial struggle and racial mixture. The statements of racial studies supported this geneticistic interpretation of history, as it was given by JA de Gobineau (1816–1882) and H.St. Chamberlain (1855–1927) represented and radicalized by A. Hitler (1889–1945) and converted into criminal practice ( ethnocide , euthanasia , genocide , Nordide ). Anthropologists such as E. von Eickstedt and human geneticists such as Eugen Fischer participated in the racial policy of the National Socialistsand O. von Verschuer, among other things through popular writings, teaching materials and especially through the creation of judicial race reports to determine whether the people examined were “of Jewish descent” and thus fell under the provisions of the Nuremberg Race Laws.
To this day, little is known about the human genetic basis ( human genetics ) and almost nothing at all about the frequency distribution of psychological characteristics in human populations. The only exception is the test intelligence . The Stanford-Binet intelligence test and its successors were constructed with the cultural environment of Euro-Americans in mind and were often conducted in the interest of social discrimination and screening (SJ Gould). The results are therefore not to be interpreted as genetically determined group differences.
In the race-theoretical view of history it was assumed that the development of culture ( cultural evolution ) depends on the genetic makeup of the respective population. This can be countered by the fact that the respective biogeographical conditions – above all the occurrence of plant and animal species suitable for domestication ( becoming domestic animals ) – decisively determined the further development of culture (the word “culture” originally referred to plant cultivation). If one had exchanged the populations of Europe and Australia about 10,000 years ago, the history and cultural development on both continents would probably not have been significantly different:“It is not genes, but continents that make history” (J. Diamond). Anthropogeography , anthropography , ethnology , eugenics , genetics , human biology , human ethology , humanity , human sciences , human ecology




