Francis Bacon’s Inductive Method: Summary and Outline. What is the Baconian Method and How Does it Work.
Francis Bacon
Scientific research is not based solely on the senses nor solely on the intellect. If the intellect on its own produces only arbitrary and unfruitful notions and if the senses on the other hand give only disordered and inconclusive indications, science cannot constitute itself as true knowledge and fruitful in results unless it imposes on sensible experience the discipline of the intellect and on it the discipline of sensible experience. The procedure that realizes this requirement is, according to Bacon, that of induction .
His philosophy aims to restore the dominion of man over nature that God granted him at the time of creation. Bacon criticizes all philosophy preceding him, especially the Greek one, because it lacked a practical purpose, but aimed at knowing for the pleasure of knowing and was completely devoid of practical results. He also criticizes Aristotelianism because it states that truth is not “daughter” of the authority of the ancients, but is “daughter temporis” that is, truth is achieved through the collaboration of scholars of each generation.
How the inductive method works
For him, the method allows man to dominate nature and is, contrary to that of Aristotle (deductive method – syllogisms), an inductive method. This method is composed of two parts:
- Pars destruens (destructive part), consists in clearing the mind of false prejudices (IDOLA) that have invaded the human intellect;
- Pars construens (constructive part), consists in the exposition and justification of the rules of that method which alone can bring the human mind back into contact with reality.
The selection and elimination on which this induction is based presupposes in the first place the collection and description of the collected facts : collection and description of particular facts: collection and description that Bacon calls natural and experimental history, because it must not be imagined or devised, but collected from experience, that is, dictated by nature itself. But natural and experimental history is so varied and vast that it would confuse the intellect rather than help it if it were not composed and arranged in a suitable order.
The tables
For this purpose, tables serve, which are collections of cases or examples (instantiae) according to a method or order that makes such collections suitable to the needs of the intellect.
- Tabulae Praesentia (the tables of presence), will then be the collection of known instances, that is, of the cases in which a certain “nature”, for example, heat, usually presents itself;
- Tabulae Absentiae (the tables of absence), will instead collect those cases that are devoid of the nature in question even though they are close to or connected to those that present it;
- Tabulae Graduum (the tables of degrees or comparisons), will instead collect those instances or cases in which the sought nature is found in different degrees, greater or lesser: this must be done either by comparing its increase and its decrease in the same subject or by comparing its magnitude in different subjects, compared with each other.
Once these tables have been formed, the real work of induction begins: the first phase of which must be negative, that is, it must consist “in excluding those natures which are not found in some cases in which the given nature is present or are found in some case in which it is absent or increases in some case in which the given nature decreases or decreases in some case in which the given nature increases”.
The positive part of the induction will begin only after this long and difficult work of exclusion, with the formulation of a provisional hypothesis about the studied form, which Bacon calls Vindematio Prima (first grape harvest).
The idols
As for the Idola, their function is to make men aware of those false notions that clutter their minds and bar their way to the truth. To get rid of them, the first step that must be taken is to identify them. Bacon identifies four:
- Idola Tribus : these are the ghosts of the tribe , that is, the prejudices of the entire human race, defined by Bacon as a tribe. The human intellect mixes its own nature with that of things, deforming and transfiguring it. They are rooted in the nature of man and in his faculties, that is, in the senses, in the intellect, in the will and in the passions. The intellect can be subject to interference from the will and the passions and is conditioned by current opinions. The human mind is satisfied with arbitrary generalizations and once it has formed an opinion it tends to ignore contrary evidence;
- Idola Specus : these are the ghosts of the cave that come from the single individual, from his interiority, it is considered as a cave because it is a term that recalls the cavern that Plato spoke of. As in Plato’s Myth, the representations of the prisoners are determined by the particular condition in which their life takes place. So also the cognitive activity of each man has a particular cave or grotto in which the light of nature is dispersed and corrupted; or because of the nature proper and singular of each, or because of his education,….. The spirit of single individuals is varied and changeable, and almost fortuitous. Therefore, the idols of the cave, draw their origin from the specific nature of the soul and body of the individual;
- Idola Fori : they are the ghosts of the forum, that is, of the square. They derive from the communion and relationships that men have with each other and are the most annoying of all, precisely because they are linked to language;
- Idola Theatri : these are the ghosts of the theatre , that is, previous philosophies understood by Bacon as fables suitable to be represented in a theatre. They are the prejudices found in comedies and in theatre texts , that is, in philosophical writings. In particular, Bacon classifies three types of idola of the theatre: sophistic idols, based on common unproven experiences; empirical idols, based on a few accurate experiments; and superstitious idols, based on an uncritical mixture of philosophy with theology and traditions.




